News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by treyd on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @09:53AM (#38084832)
If someone ran a print shop and printed out my articles into a book called "Collected works by Trey on HN" or something and didn't give me a cent then yeah I'd be thrilled, because it's a validation of my work. I already published the articles, they're doing all the work to put them into print, what right do I really have to claim part of the sales?

But if they claimed that they wrote the content then they would be defrauding their customers, since saying they wrote them would just be lying. You don't need intellectual property for fraud (as in "lying for material gain") to exist and be bad. At the very least it would be dishonest academically speaking and they should be criticized for it.

Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by mistrial9 on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @02:13PM (#38089046)
you would throw out hundreds of years of copyright law on a whim. This is economic suicide for independent creatives. The most tragic part of this is that creatives themselves, immersed in creativity, see no rhyme or reason to stop the flow. Over time, those that grow old or weak are discarded with no rights to their own work. Yes, it is that bad.
Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by treyd on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @04:29PM (#38090919)
Have you listened to artists and creatives talk about copyright recently? Especially ones that publish on newer, digital distribution platforms like YouTube? There's numerous more thorough critiques of copyright law and calls to abolish it from across the political spectrum.

You're mischaracterizing me by suggesting that it's "economic suicide", as I said in my original comment in this thread:

> But we shouldn't be responding to that by clinging harder to schemes that have outlived their usefulness, we should be developing new models for funding production.

Sure it would be disruptive if we snapped our fingers and said "no more IP starting tomorrow", there should be a gradual phasing out of these unfair protections and effort put into sustainable pro-creative models.

Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by mistrial9 on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @07:22PM (#38092700)
YouTube where the user account can be terminated without notice, and with no recourse?
Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by treyd on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @05:11PM (#38105326)
That's bad but also mostly unrelated to the main point I'm making about copyright. If anything it's supportive since part of the risk of account deletion/restriction is running afowl of their content ID system, which only exists because of strongarm corporate copyright holders.