Re:Covid Lockdowns Were a Giant Experiment. It Was a Failure
by progne on Monday October 30, 2023 @05:25PM
(#38076127)
"Teachers across America are sounding the alarm about how badly students are performing academically because of school closures and then still being advanced to the next grade level. This is a full blown crisis ..."
Re:Covid Lockdowns Were a Giant Experiment. It Was a Failure
by adamredwoods on Monday October 30, 2023 @06:32PM
(#38076865)
Bizarre end claim that I feel misses the point of why things were shut down:
>> What he could never acknowledge was that “shutting things down” didn’t stop the virus, and that keeping schools closed didn’t save kids’ lives. Then again, to understand that, you had to be willing to follow the science.
Re:Covid Lockdowns Were a Giant Experiment. It Was a Failure
by adamredwoods on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @07:34PM
(#38092776)
Kids were not affected by the virus as much as adults, so why did the article call it out? It was the passing of the virus to elder adults that the shutdown was trying to prevent.
Re:Covid Lockdowns Were a Giant Experiment. It Was a Failure
by dent9876543 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @10:54AM
(#38099002)
Because the effect doesn't really become significant until middle-age, and while the slope rises fast from there, it was always understood to be something that all but the oldest of immune systems could handle.
The shutdown was initially to protect health services from becoming overwhelmed. Although it was later re-interpreted as you suggest, that was never a purpose grounded in either good science or evidence.
Although it would have been hard to protect the virus from spreading to the middle aged, we could very easily have limited its spread amongst the oldest and most vulnerable. The size of the group is much smaller, and it would have been easier. "All" it needed was for people to focus their protection efforts. As it was, we tried to protect everyone. It was a waste of resources, and far worse than that, it failed to provide substantial protection to anyone.
https://twitter.com/nickineily/status/1717536759209136394
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bethany_McLean
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joe_Nocera
>> What he could never acknowledge was that “shutting things down” didn’t stop the virus, and that keeping schools closed didn’t save kids’ lives. Then again, to understand that, you had to be willing to follow the science.
The initial reason for imposing the measure isn’t the point.
The point is to understand whether the measure was effective.
The shutdown was initially to protect health services from becoming overwhelmed. Although it was later re-interpreted as you suggest, that was never a purpose grounded in either good science or evidence.
Although it would have been hard to protect the virus from spreading to the middle aged, we could very easily have limited its spread amongst the oldest and most vulnerable. The size of the group is much smaller, and it would have been easier. "All" it needed was for people to focus their protection efforts. As it was, we tried to protect everyone. It was a waste of resources, and far worse than that, it failed to provide substantial protection to anyone.