News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How many billions of transistors in your iPhone processor? by eru on Monday October 30, 2023 @12:42AM (#38065759)
Putting humans on the moon in the first place was mostly just grandstanding. Manned space exploration in general is mostly just entertainment. I'm glad humanity hasn't continued wasting resources on that particular endeavor.

Unmanned probes do good work for science. (Though even there I am not sure about the bang-for-the-buck compared to other alternatives.)

Have a look at '20 Breakthroughs from 20 Years of Science aboard the International Space Station' https://www.nasa.gov/missions/station/20-breakthroughs-from-...

That's the list of the 20 best things they could come up with. And it scarcely has anything that couldn't have been done cheaper with unmanned craft. And it includes gems like counting spending money as a benefit, instead of a cost.

Re:How many billions of transistors in your iPhone processor? by causi on Monday October 30, 2023 @04:13AM (#38066820)
Putting humans on the moon in the first place was mostly just grandstanding. Manned space exploration in general is mostly just entertainment.

Indeed, and I believe refusing to acknowledge that fact is actively harming not just spaceflight but manned spaceflight. We're spending tens of billions of dollars trying to set up for some bullshit useless moon base when we could be setting boots on Mars just to prove we can. If we're gonna waste money let's waste it pushing the boundaries.

Re:How many billions of transistors in your iPhone processor? by Shawnj2 on Monday October 30, 2023 @05:06AM (#38067116)
I think a moon base is actually more useful because there’s actual commercial use cases to a moon base like mining etc. and not only that but doing a mars mission is far easier and cheaper if you already have a moon base since you can make rocket fuel on the moon for cheaper in terms of delta-V if you can come up with a hydro lox chemistry design.
Re:How many billions of transistors in your iPhone processor? by causi on Monday October 30, 2023 @05:27AM (#38067262)
What could you mine on the moon that would be worth transporting home?
Re:How many billions of transistors in your iPhone processor? by ben_w on Monday October 30, 2023 @08:18AM (#38068467)
Back when people were suggesting mining it for helium-3, I remember reading a blog post that claimed the best way to get it out of the regolith would produce ridiculously high-purity metals as a side product.

It then went on to point out that the energy helium-3 density was so low, it made more sense to catapult the ingots to earth and (1) magnetically decelerate them for energy, and/or (2) burn them.

I suspect one of the best things you can build on the moon and not on Earth is an orbital ring[0]. Well, two rings, first you build one orbiting the moon, learn what the failure modes are and how to mitigate them, then you use that learning experience to export the parts for another to Earth… but I am just straight up assuming that the cost of a moon-based factory won't blow away the cost savings from the difference in delta-v going down to LEO from the Moon (with or without a lunar orbital ring) vs. going up to LEO from the surface of the Earth.

(Also: not mining, but I imagine it would be a great place for dangerous research, inspired by all the people suggesting COVID leaked out of a gain-of-function research laboratory).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_ring

Re:How many billions of transistors in your iPhone processor? by tim333 on Monday October 30, 2023 @09:48AM (#38069431)
I gather there are asteroids with a lot of gold and platinum. Just crash one into the moon and then mine the debris.
Re:How many billions of transistors in your iPhone processor? by eru on Monday October 30, 2023 @11:36PM (#38079973)
I'm not sure that's better than mining them in-situ?
Re:How many billions of transistors in your iPhone processor? by eru on Monday October 30, 2023 @05:46AM (#38067382)
That might be true, but that doesn't mean the moonbase needs to be manned.

Especially since the signal lag from earth is so small, so you can even use remote human operators for many tasks instead of investing a lot in AI.