Re:How deep is the brain? The shallow brain hypothesis
by mjan22640 on Monday October 30, 2023 @04:42AM
(#38066979)
A neuron is analogous to a 3d integrated circuit rather to a transistor. A molecule acts like a transistor https://medium.com/the-physics-arxiv-blog/the-origin-of-life...
Changes in mechanical pressure, electric field, other molecules attachment, photon absorption, can control the conductivity.
Organic semiconductors designed to fit like lego bricks to naturally build the desired structure are IMHO the way to go to produce 3d circuits, rather than layered silicone litography.
Re:How deep is the brain? The shallow brain hypothesis
by ben_w on Monday October 30, 2023 @06:25AM
(#38067636)
> silicone
I've seen this particular mistake a lot recently. New and exciting auto-corrupt from the latest version of iOS?
Given that our brains rewire themselves live, which ANNs can only do by being excessively connected and updating weights to/from zero, silicone (I'm thinking mainly the oil form) may be a better inspiration than lego.
Second, there is no need to compare brains to neural networks because brains are neural networks. Neurons form vertices and axons edges connecting the aforementioned. What you are perhaps thinking of are artificial neural networks - most of which are very dissimilar to brains. But even then you are wrong. Artificial Izhikevich and Hodgkin-Huxley neural networks attempts to closely mimic the behavior of real neurons.
While deep, hierarchical artificial neural networks have been more successful than biologically plausible ones, that may be because the technology isn't ready yet. After all, the perceptron was invented in the 1950's but didn't become prominent until the 2010's (or so). Perhaps we need new memories that better map to (real) neural network topologies, or perhaps 3d chips that can pack transistors in the same way brains pack neurons.