It's very easy to understand what a dual space is. It's very hard to understand why you should care. Many of the constructions that use it seem arbitrary: if finite vector spaces are isomorphic to their duals, why bother caring about the distinction? There are answers to this question, but you get them somewhere between 1 and 5 years later. It is a pedagogical nightmare.
Every concept should have both a definition and a clear reason to believe you should bother caring about it, such as a problem with the theory that is solved by the introduction of that concept. Without the motivating examples, definitions are pointless (except, apparently, to a certain breed of mathematicians).
I've read something like 100 math textbooks at this point. I would rate their pedagogical quality between an F and a D+ at best. I have never read a good math textbook. I don't know what it is, but mathematicians are determined to make the subject awful for everybody who doesn't think the way they do.
(I hope someday to prove that it's possible to write a good math textbook by doing it, but I'm a long way away from that goal.)
I'm not the person you were originally replying to, but I have taken all the appropriate classes and still find the dual space to be mostly inappropriately motivated. There is a style of person for whom the motivation is simply "given V, we can generate V* and it's a vector space, therefore it's worth studying". But that is not, IMO, sufficient. A person the subject can't make sense of that understanding the alternative: not defining it, and discarding it, and ultimately why one approach was stolen over the others.
I think in 50 years we will look back on the way pure math was written today as a great tragedy of this age that is thankfully lost to time.
That could very well be true. I mean just a 100 years ago mathematics (and most education) consisted almost exclusively of the most insane drudgery imaginable. I do sometimes wonder what the world could have been like if we didn't gate contributions in math or physics behind learning classical greek.
I do think that some of the issues come down to different learning styles. I personally like getting the definition up front- it keeps me less confused, and I can properly appreciate the examples down the line. The way Axler introduces the dual space was really charming for me, and it clicked in a way that "vectors as columns, covectors as rows" never did. But that's not everyone! It's by no means everyone in pure math, and its definitely not everyone who needs to use math. I've met people far better than me who struggled just because the resources weren't tuned towards them- there's a huge gap.
I submit that not only the subject is not well understood, but even the name of the subject is wrong. It should be called "The study of orthogonality". This change of perspective will naturally lead to discussion of orthogonal polynomials, orthogonal functions, create a bridge to representation theory and (on the other end) to the applications in data science. What say you? :-)
What you say regarding the seeming coincidental nature of "real world" applications is basically correct (with correlation specifically there's some other stuff going on, it isn't that surprising, but in general), but unavoidable for any aspect of pure mathematics. Math is the study of formal systems, and the real world wasn't cooked up on a black board. If we can demonstrate that some component of reality obeys laws which map onto axioms, we can apply math to the world. But re-framing an entire field to work with one specific real world use (not even imo the most important real world use!) is just silly.
I love the idea of encouraging students early on to look at different areas of math and see the connections. But linear algebra is connected in more ways to more things than just using an inner product to pull out a nice basis. Noticing that polynomials, measurable functions, etc are vectors is possible without reframing the entire field, and there are lots of uses of linear algebra that don't require a norm! Hell representation theory only does in some situations.
However, there's plenty of value in the formal systems stuff. Algebraic formalization is just one way of looking at the simplest forms on linear algebra, but there really isn't any other way of looking at abstract algebra. Or model theory, or the weirder spectral stuff. Or algebraic topology. And when linear algebra comes up in those contexts (which it does often, it's the most well developed field of mathematics), it's best understood from an abstract, formal perspective.
And, just as a personal note, I personally would never have pursued mathematics if it were presented any other way. I'm not trying to use that as an argument- as we've discussed, the problem with math pedagogy certainly isn't a lack of abstract definitions and rigor. But there are people who think like me, and the reason the textbooks are written like that is because that's what was helpful to the authors when they were learning. It wasn't inflicted on our species from the outside.
The author writing a book after 30 years of learning, thinking, talking with other people cannot easily reconstruct what was helpful and what wasn't. Creating 1-dimensional representation of the state of mind (which constitues "understanding") is a virtually impossible task. And here algebraic formalism comes to the rescue. "Definition" - "Theorem" - "Corollary" structure looks like a silver bullet, it fits very well in a linear format of a book. Unfortunately, this format is totally inadequate when it comes to passing knowledge. Very often, you can't understand A before you understand B, and you can't understand B before understanding A - the concepts in math are very often "entangled" (again, I'm talking about understanding, not formal consistency). You need examples, motivations, questions and answers - the whole arsenal of pedagogical tricks.
Some other form of presentation must be found to make it easier to encode the knowledge. Not sure what this form might be. Maybe some annotated book format will do, not sure. It should be a result of a collective effort IMO. Please think about it.
BTW, this is not a criticism of LADR book in particular. The proofs are concise and beautiful. But... the compression is very lossy in terms of representing knowledge.
I really can't emphasize enough that this is exactly how I learn things. I don't claim to be a majority! But saying that no one can learn from that sort of in-order definition-first method is like saying no one can do productive work before 6am. It sucks that morning people control the world, but its hardly a human universal to sleep in.
> Some other form of presentation must be found to make it easier to encode the knowledge. Not sure what this form might be. Maybe some annotated book format will do, not sure. It should be a result of a collective effort IMO.
I 100% agree. Have you seen the napkin project? I don't love the exposition on everything, but it builds up ideas pretty nicely, showing uses and motivation mixed in with the definitions. I've been trying to write some resources of my own intended for interested laymen, so more focus on motivation and examples and less on proofs and such. I like the challenge of trying to cut to the core of why we define things a certain way- though I'm biased towards "because it makes the formal logic nice" as an explanation.
Will take a look, thanks! I think I understand your point. I want to thank you for the productive discussion!
Linear algebra studies linearity, not (just) orthogonality. Orthogonality requires an inner product, and there isn't a canonical one on a linear structure, nor is there any one on e.g. spaces over finite fields. Mathematics, like programming, has an interface segregation principle. By writing implementations to a more minimal interface, we can reuse them for e.g. modules or finite spaces. It also makes it clear that questions like "are these orthogonal" depend on "what's the product", which can be useful to make sense of e.g. Hermite polynomials, where you use a weighted inner product.
Of course there is. Covariance looks like an L2 norm (what you're calling the scalar product) because it is an L2 norm. They're the exact same object.
From what you said there, it seems like you tried to approach linear algebra from nearly random directions- and often from the end rather than the beginning. If you're in it for the computation, Axler definitely isn't for you. There are texts specifically on numeric programming- they'll jump straight to the real world use. If you want to understand it from a pure math perspective, I'd recommend taking a step back and tackle a textbook of your choosing in order. The definition of a dual space makes a lot more sense once you have a vector space down.