Re:The Philosophy of Humor: What Makes Something Funny? (2022)
by naasking on Sunday October 29, 2023 @10:55AM
(#38059167)
> in fact we can construct test jokes that abide by all of them and are still deeply unfunny
They could be necessary rules, but not sufficient. Necessary in the sense that, can you construct a joke that doesn't abide by one of the rules, but is still funny?
Re:The Philosophy of Humor: What Makes Something Funny? (2022)
by aranchelk on Sunday October 29, 2023 @11:21AM
(#38059393)
If it’s a rule that I can break and make a funny joke or follow and make an unfunny joke, I don’t think it can (even colloquially) be called a “rule” — maybe a predictive element, maybe nothing.
Agreed, theories are testable, all of these theories are easily disprovable, in fact we can construct test jokes that abide by all of them and are still deeply unfunny.
One of the most counterintuitive elements of humor is breaking the flow by saying a wrong word and then correcting one’s self completely tanks jokes.
I have a comedian in mind who does this at least once per his weekly show — cue a grown from the audience and polite applause — it’s a friendly crowd.
Explain this and I think you’re on your way to a proper theory.