The reason you have to defend yourself is that your style is currently less idiomatic than their style. The caveat of non-idiomatic choices is that you have to defend them either indefinitely or until the idioms change, whichever comes first. What I find odd is when people make a non-mainstream choice and aren't willing to put in the effort to back it up - swimming against the stream is great, but you have to be able to explain to people why you're doing it or be tough enough to ignore them when they ask.
I don't even have a problem with people who want to put semi-colons all over the place, I am just tired of having to defend myself on why I choose not to. And it feels kind of odd that I have to, because I am not the one adding redundant characters everywhere