I logged back into his gmail account using this information [this was before the time that Google started to flag logins from unusual IP addresses] and found out that he was doing this as contract work for several legitimate companies.
There in the email were messages back and forth between himself and various marketing managers at those companies about sites he'd attacked and placed spam links in.
Of course if you're the sort of user who uses the same password on every site, then it benefits you a little bit if the site hashes the password. The site admin or an attacker can still easily steal your password when you log in, so the benefit is small. But by doing this you're trusting every site, which is stupid.
Users should use a completely different, randomly generated password for every site, then whether or not the site hashes the password doesn't matter.
SEO continues to both amaze and frustrate me. The more money that gets traded hands based on search, the more brutal and intricate the cheaters are going to become. A lot of the black hat stuff we see now is heavy-handed bullshit, but something like this, if done very carefully, would both be extremely difficult to detect and very lucrative. The canonical thing is smart as hell. You could make that change and, unless site owners specifically went looking for it, nobody would ever see. I could imagine hackers breaking into dozens or hundreds of domains and then auctioning off as very small number of SEO links. This would provide the maximum value for the minimal footprint on the site. Heck, take it up another notch and rent out the space.