News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don’t Be Evil: How Google Screwed a Startup by ajross on Thursday April 05, 2012 @01:53PM (#3803714)
The second paragraph seems like something one could test. Have you?

Fraud detection is just hard. And my expectation is that for every legitimate friendly fire instance there are six or ten "marginal fraudsters" trying to spin their troubles with Google via blog posts like the one in the link.

I clicked on this thinking it would be a clear case of Google doing something "evil", and had to read through very carefully before I figured out that it was just another account freeze. Meh. If it's seriously $40k, then sue them and figure out what really happened in discovery. That would be a blog post I'd want to read.

Re:Don’t Be Evil: How Google Screwed a Startup by pbhjpbhj on Thursday April 05, 2012 @03:27PM (#3804178)
>a clear case of Google doing something "evil" //

Using $40k of a service (ad space in this instance) and then refusing to return the service providers calls and emails for over 12 months may not be "evil" per se but it's certainly on the malevolent side.

If it ruined someone’s livelihood then I'd say it's getting to be in the locus of what could well be described as "evil".

For a company to do this without apology demonstrates a pretty serious ethical deficit (assuming we have the full story before us).

Re:Don’t Be Evil: How Google Screwed a Startup by ajross on Thursday April 05, 2012 @04:38PM (#3804503)
You're taking the linked post on an awful lot of (IMHO, unverifiable and undeserved) faith. Yes, if everything they say is true, Google are jerks at best. But a blog post does not a reputation for honesty make, sorry. Even PayPal doesn't hit verifiably honest saints more than one a year or so.

Look, I don't know anything about "hatchlings", I'm just saying I'm not going to believe a post like this prima facie. They look like a garden variety spammy facebook game to me. That's a market pretty well known for playing SEO games and gaming ad systems.

Are these guys guilty or not? No idea. Fight it out, get some evidence, and then come to the public for support.

Re:Don’t Be Evil: How Google Screwed a Startup by yeldarb on Thursday April 05, 2012 @06:15PM (#3804929)
I agree that you shouldn't just take us at our word (and that's why we included as much documentation as we could to support our case).

But it would make it a heck of a lot easier to defend ourselves if Google had actually accused us of doing something wrong. To this day we're not even sure what we're alleged to have done to get our account banned.

Re:Don’t Be Evil: How Google Screwed a Startup by m8urn on Thursday April 05, 2012 @08:27PM (#3805378)
There's no reason to think the story isn't true either. This is exactly the same scenario thousands have experienced over the years. Google sends the first automated e-mail, the user appeals, then gets a second canned response from Google. I don't think the wording of either email has even changed for years. Just look at how many others who have just posted here have had similar experiences. Look around the internet a bit and you will see that the number of people suddenly banned from adsense for life then stonewalled by Google is HUGE.
Re:Don’t Be Evil: How Google Screwed a Startup by mistercow on Thursday April 05, 2012 @02:13PM (#3803814)
>The second paragraph seems like something one could test.

I do not think it would be ethical to test it directly. But you don't have to search far to find people who have had their accounts crashed by angry exes.