News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I’d like a “license type” setting for GitHub projects by mindcrime on Thursday April 05, 2012 @11:46AM (#3803068)
Many people don't know what "copyleft" is, so "restrictive" makes more sense.

I could see that holding true among the general population, but among developers? What developer who's going to be browsing Github doesn't know what copyleft means?

There are more restrictions.

Yes and no. Even licenses like the Apache License do impose restrictions of sorts, and the whole "permissive" vs "restrictive" thing is hardly a binary proposition. It's a continuum... and that's not even considering that saying "restrictive" raise the issue of "restrictive for who?" Yes, arguably the GPL is more restrictive in terms of how a developer can interact with GPL'd code, but from an end-user perspective the GPL is "more free" in a sense.

All of that said, I get the point behind a simple binary "restrictive/permissive" flag, and I think most people would intuitively grok the general sense of it. I'm not opposed to it, but I think we could do better.

Hmmm... that raises an interesting point... does Github have any sort of notion of explicit support for DOAP[1] files? Encouraging people to use DOAP files might be a better answer anyway.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Description_of_a_Project

Re:Why I’d like a “license type” setting for GitHub projects by nkassis on Thursday April 05, 2012 @04:15PM (#3804402)
"Yes and no. Even licenses like the Apache License do impose restrictions of sorts, and the whole "permissive" vs "restrictive" thing is hardly a binary proposition. It's a continuum... and that's not even considering that saying "restrictive" raise the issue of "restrictive for who?" Yes, arguably the GPL is more restrictive in terms of how a developer can interact with GPL'd code, but from an end-user perspective the GPL is "more free" in a sense."

This is an important point. How many people know that they should list their changes when using EDIT:Some licenses or the patent stuff in the Apache license etc...

These tags don't really make sense.

Re:Why I’d like a “license type” setting for GitHub projects by mindcrime on Thursday April 05, 2012 @04:56PM (#3804588)
or the patent stuff in the Apache license

Exactly. That's a great example of what I had in mind. Nobody talks about it, but that stuff is there and is important.