News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The OSI Deprogrammer by tptacek on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @12:01AM (#38008996)
I sort of agree that "OSI" is really weakening his argument, and that he could take clearer aim at the classical Internet layering model (network, transport, application) --- even that simple layering is obsolete now. But it'd still be a straw man! We even run DNS over HTTP at this point.
Re:The OSI Deprogrammer by derefr on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @12:55AM (#38009283)
I think that the "OSI" he's speaking about isn't an engineering tool, a thing people would use to construct systems; rather, this "OSI" is a way of modelling systems that exist — systems that, of course, were not implemented by people thinking about OSI. It's an analytical modelling tool, a thing applied to a system retrospectively in an attempt to understand it, break it down along abstract rather than concrete lines. Like the various flavors of literary criticism.

Except in the case of OSI, it's not a reputable analytical tool from the perspective of actual academics; it's rather a discredited one. Instead, it's only lay-people with an outdated view of the state-of-scientific-practice who attempt to apply the discredited tool. And this article is an attempt to get those lay-people to stop doing that.

Compare/contrast how the layman may often think that Freudian psychoanalysis is still in use in psychiatry — and may even try to apply it themselves to understand someone's motivations. Much to the chagrin of psychiatrists.

Re:The OSI Deprogrammer by robertgraham on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @02:17AM (#38009719)
Yea, it's not about engineers constructing systems. I mean, engineers do frequently pretend their creations fit the OSI model, but they work backwards to make it appear to conform to orthodoxy.

The issue is about education. People teach the model, or some variation of it. It teaches misconceptsion, such as how Ethernet and the Internet are integrated in a single network stack rather than being independent networks. It leads to professionals in IT and cybersecurity who continue to hold this misconception.

Re:The OSI Deprogrammer by derefr on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @01:35PM (#38015586)
> It teaches misconceptsion, such as how Ethernet and the Internet are integrated in a single network stack rather than being independent networks.

It really opened up a whole world of understanding for me when I decided to find out what happened when I searched "RFC 1." It made me realize that "the birth of the Internet" as we know it, was essentially the moment of the deployment of the first network switch (the BB&N IMP), isolating physical networks' electrical properties and collision domains from one-another and using DSPs to arbitrarily re-write packets between different signalling standards — thus rendering uniformity of physical/electrical media and LAN signalling standards, completely irrelevant.

Until that moment, I had always thought of "the Internet" as a thing that grew like a social network, with people "switching over" from using whatever networking equipment and signalling they had been using, to using Internet networking equipment and standards. But no! The whole clever thing about "The Internet" is that it didn't do that! It just took all the random proprietary networks that people had built, and connected them together, by coming up with a set of standards for how the networks would speak to one-another at their border gateways, and leaving everything else up to implementation!

And, in that view, the whole "layer separation" concept — of there being such a thing as an "IP packet" that bubbles up to userland separately from any delivery enveloping — wasn't fundamental to The Internet; in fact, existing protocols that were vertically integrated continued to work, being rewritten into something else when they reached the AS border gateway. The "layer separation" was an optimization to allow new "post-Internet" protocols to get by without AS-border-gateway packet rewriting, rather just re-enveloping, by separately standardizing "the contents of the envelope" and abstracting away "the envelope itself." But network stacks continued to support non-layer-separated communication for decades afterward!

Re:The OSI Deprogrammer by aidenn0 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @01:48AM (#38009552)
I don't see DoH as any more of an issue for describing the layers than PPPoE is.