News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Face Investigation for Terrorism by bawolff on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @08:31AM (#37998211)
> Numerically speaking the IDF have killed a lot more civilians than Hamas. As have the US for that matter, literally hundreds of thousands of civilians killed in Iraq.

I don't know why "numerically" matters. There is a big difference morally between someone accidentally killed while persuing a legal military target, and intentionally gunning down a rave or children at a day care.

Re:I Face Investigation for Terrorism by hef19898 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @08:42AM (#37998336)
Civilian infrastructure and housing are decidedly no legitimate milotary targets. Never have been, and this makes air power such a bad choice when fighting insurgencies, it is to indiscriminate.
Re:I Face Investigation for Terrorism by bawolff on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @09:36AM (#37999001)
Whether or not it is a legit legal military target depends on if it is being used for a military purposes and how "porportional" the military benefit of targeting it is relitive to the civilian damage targeting it would cause.

The idea that if someone converts a house into an ammunition store depot it can never be targeted ever under international law is just straight up wrong.

Of course how that translates to what is being done on the ground is very complex.

Re:I Face Investigation for Terrorism by hef19898 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @10:09AM (#37999384)
You make the point about fighting insurgencies and guerilla opponents being so damn hard very well, I think. Not the least beimg, that said insurgents do not really count as an armed opponent.

Regarding the house being an ammunition depot: Sure, legitimate target. Blowing up the whole highrise, debatable. Blowing up the neighbouring highrise, even more debatable. And airstrikes are nowhere precise enough for that kind of work.

Re:I Face Investigation for Terrorism by xdennis on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @01:19PM (#38002221)
> that said insurgents do not really count as an armed opponent

Insurgents are people who are fighting their own government (with guns) so they are armed, but they're not fighting Hamas, they're fighting Israel, so they're not insurgents.

Many of them don't even wear military uniforms in combat, that makes them unlawful combatants under the Geneva Conventions and don't have rights. They almost always attack civilians, so they're terrorists.

Re:I Face Investigation for Terrorism by hef19898 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:06PM (#38002922)
Yeah, isurgents, partisans and whatever you wanna call them are not regular combatants. You what that means? That the rule of land warefare don't apply to them. That makes fighting them a police action, one that has to follow basic human rights (detention, fair trials, the works). Unless you are fine being the baddy, in which case go full out Soviet Uniom in Afghanistan, USA in Vietnam or SS on the Eastern Front rear areas.

You know what that doesn't mean? That those people, and everyone in their vincinity, forfeit all, every and each right they ever had. Last time I checked, the IDF had pretty decent rules of engagement around that very question. On paper, and unfortunately rather loosly respected, but still.

Re:I Face Investigation for Terrorism by bawolff on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:58PM (#38003626)
> Yeah, isurgents, partisans and whatever you wanna call them are not regular combatants. You what that means? That the rule of land warefare don't apply to them

??? I don't think that follows. What is your basis for this.

Re:I Face Investigation for Terrorism by ignoramous on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @10:07PM (#38008305)
(not my view) What OP means is you don't bring an airforce and a navy and an army to a gang fight, unless of course you're okay with destruction of urban areas.
Re:I Face Investigation for Terrorism by tomjen3 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:01PM (#38002858)
A six month old baby that burns to death is in just as much pay when it is because it was doused in gasoline by a terrorist as because it was set on fire by an Israeli airstrike.

You may care about the finer legal minutia, but I doubt it matters very much to the death people and their relatives.

Re:I Face Investigation for Terrorism by sneak on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @03:30AM (#38010199)
> There is a big difference morally between someone accidentally killed while persuing a legal military target, and intentionally gunning down a rave or children at a day care.

Not all of us agree with this. The idea of “legal military target” grows out of the idea of “just war”, which many of us reject outright.

Re:I Face Investigation for Terrorism by bawolff on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @06:00PM (#38018940)
i would think it more grows out of the distinction between first degree murder and either self-defense or involuntary manslaughter we find in ordinary laws.