News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:World shift to clean energy is unstoppable, IEA report says by bryanlarsen on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @05:59AM (#37996841)
> By far the most environmentally friendly thing to do currently is to keep existing vehicles running for longer, until they are eventually traded for something more efficient.

That is not true. The breakeven point vis-a-vis carbon emissions is 2 years, assuming the average milage of 13,500 miles. An EV is better than an equivalent new gasoline car if it drives at least 13,500 miles before being scrapped. A new EV is better than an equivalent used gasoline car if it drives at least 27,000 more miles before being scrapped.

https://arstechnica.com/cars/2022/04/new-ev-vs-old-beater-wh...

> I'm yet to be convinced that these EV batteries will serve out the 10 years they claim

There are lots of >10 year old Leafs and Model S's on the road. And Leaf is the worst case scenario. Without temperature management they wear out a lot quicker than every other car battery does. And remember that used batteries don't get thrown out, they generally get repurposed into stationary storage. They can be recycled but generally aren't because they're too useful as is.

Re:World shift to clean energy is unstoppable, IEA report says by bArray on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @09:33AM (#37998960)
From the article:

> The idea is right up there with the myth that the United States is powered almost entirely by coal and that EVs are thus worse polluters than gas engines. The reality is that coal makes up about 20 to 22 percent of the national power grid.

Coal is not the only problem. Power stations can also use some forms of oil, gas (whether they call it green or not, is still a pollutant), etc. Building the infrastructure for green energy itself has a carbon footprint that takes a while to pay off.

Secondly, in the Reuters article it assumes the comparison vehicle is brand new, and starts with a carbon offset: https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/when-d...

Under the assumption you already have the Toyota, and the question is "should I scrap my Toyota to buy an electric car", and the electricity is generated from 20% coal (not including other carbon sources), the answer is simply no - keep driving your old car.

> There are lots of >10 year old Leafs and Model S's on the road. And Leaf is the worst case scenario. Without temperature management they wear out a lot quicker than every other car battery does. And remember that used batteries don't get thrown out, they generally get repurposed into stationary storage. They can be recycled but generally aren't because they're too useful as is.

I think the Nissan Leaf has survivor bias - it's one electric car that was successful, plus all the ones with failed batteries are no longer on the road, you only see the good ones still driving. What's really important though is the remaining capacity. An EV that claims 500 miles that can only do 200 miles after some years will start to become a hindrance.

As the capacity of the battery drops, I imagine the internal resistance of the battery increases and more of that energy gets converted to heat. Put simply, the EV gets less efficient as time goes on. Unfortunately we don't really have good numbers for this yet.

Re:World shift to clean energy is unstoppable, IEA report says by bryanlarsen on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @10:51AM (#37999989)
Take the graph from the reuters article. Shift the red line down so the origin starts at 0. That represents the removal of the initial carbon offset, aka the "used Toyota" scenario. Notice that the new red line and the old green line now intersect at about year 2 instead of at year 1 like they did when the gasoline car included the carbon produced during production.

> Unfortunately we don't really have good numbers for this yet

Just survey drivers of 10 year old Model S's.

Re:World shift to clean energy is unstoppable, IEA report says by guerby on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @12:28PM (#38001499)
2021 article based on probably even older emission data and price points.

Battery and EV production process moves quite fast.

Re:World shift to clean energy is unstoppable, IEA report says by tzs on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @01:14PM (#38002150)
> And remember that used batteries don't get thrown out, they generally get repurposed into stationary storage. They can be recycled but generally aren't because they're too useful as is.

How does that work from a consumer point of view?

Say I've got an EV and it eventually needs a battery replacement. I take it to the dealer and they swap batteries and charge me $B for the new battery and $L for labor. Let's say the old battery is worth $S on the market for batteries for stationary story.

I assume that the normal procedure is that the dealer keeps the old battery after a swap. If that is the base does the $B I pay include a discount for the $S the dealer can get reselling the old battery?

If not can I tell the dealer I want to keep the old battery? If so is there some established marketplace I can then sell it for stationary storage?

Re:World shift to clean energy is unstoppable, IEA report says by bryanlarsen on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:07PM (#38002940)
The warranty on Tesla (and others similar) goes to 8yrs/120k miles. So any swap you pay for is going to be on a 120k mile+ car. At that stage, putting a new battery in is kind of lopsided. Not many people will spend 5 figures on a car that used, they'll sell it instead. And whoever buys it will probably just drive it instead of replacing the battery. A car with a battery at 70-85% of new capacity is still useful. And that'll likely continue until the car is scrapped, when the scrap dealer pulls out the battery and sells it on.

If you do want to replace the battery, I would think you're more likely to put a used battery in than a new one. And scrap dealers are normally quite open to swaps.