News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mazda Slaps Developer with Cease-and-Desist for DIY Smart... by AceJohnny2 on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:45PM (#37992009)
Are you aware that copyright law is the foundation of FOSS licenses?
Re:Mazda Slaps Developer with Cease-and-Desist for DIY Smart... by jimnotgym on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:52PM (#37992080)
You wouldn't need it if copyright didn't exist in the first place
Re:Mazda Slaps Developer with Cease-and-Desist for DIY Smart... by AceJohnny2 on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:59PM (#37992152)
Of course you would. For example, thanks to copyright law, Linksys was forced to share their Linux customizations to run on router hardware, which led to the creation of the OpenWRT project.

Without copyright law, any actor can take your open system and close it.

Re:Mazda Slaps Developer with Cease-and-Desist for DIY Smart... by Filligree on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:44PM (#37992628)
A lot of people are fine with that. Look at everyone who uses the BSD or MIT license.
Re:Mazda Slaps Developer with Cease-and-Desist for DIY Smart... by AceJohnny2 on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:06PM (#37992811)
The fact that they have the option to choose it is different than it being the only possibility.
Re:Mazda Slaps Developer with Cease-and-Desist for DIY Smart... by maxerickson on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:01PM (#37992182)
"Free Software" requires making source code available to users. If copyright didn't exist, there would not even be a hypothetical mechanism to require that of publishers.
Re:Mazda Slaps Developer with Cease-and-Desist for DIY Smart... by aleph_minus_one on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:17PM (#37992908)
> You wouldn't need it if copyright didn't exist in the first place

No popular open source license that I am aware of attempts to emulate a no-copyright situation:

If there was no copyright, you could not force anybody to provide the source code of any derivative work (situation for copyleft licenses). On the other hand, in a no-copyright situation, you are not able to sue anybody who attempts to reverse-engineer such a derived binary blob and publish the reverse-engineered source code.

Thus, an open-source license that attempts to emulate a no-copyright situation would in my opinion have clauses like the following:

- you are allowed to create binary-only derived works, and are allowed to sell copies of it

- you must not sue anybody who redistributes these copies (even for money)

- you must not disallow any licensees to reverse-engineer these executables

- you must not disallow any owner of a copy to create any derivative work (even using reverse-engineering techni, as long as this work is licenses under this license. This in particular means that, if you create a derivative work, you have to take care that you cannot redistribute copies that (statically) link the work with parts for which this is disallowed