News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fedora mulls ARM as a primary architecture by ComputerGuru on Wednesday April 04, 2012 @01:58PM (#3798865)
What's the advantage of a ARM-based high-end laptop vs an x86-based high-end laptop?

I'll bite: nothing. In fact, only disadvantages abound. You won't get i5 or i7 like performance at the same value or wattage from an ARM for a few more years.

Re:Fedora mulls ARM as a primary architecture by lovamova on Wednesday April 04, 2012 @03:19PM (#3799339)
No fans!? I don't need high-end performance, just good performance with long lasting battery and no heat.
Re:Fedora mulls ARM as a primary architecture by ComputerGuru on Wednesday April 04, 2012 @04:30PM (#3799683)
Your entire reply is based on the fallacy that a high-end ARM would operate in the same way a low-end ARM does. Most of the energy and die space, etc. etc. in a CPU is dedicated to the caches. L1, L2, and sometimes L3. And they keep getting bigger even as the rest of the CPU gets smaller.

A low-end ARM doesn't worry about heat because it's "underpowered" (loosely speaking). But if you want to approach the performance of an i5, the natural side effects will be tons of heat, much, much worse battery life, and even then, only mediocre performance.

There's a lot more to a CPU than RISC vs CISC. Intel has put decades of research into chip design and various instruction-level optimizations that take place within the CPU. You're making a big mistake assuming ARM can just directly scale their smartphone/tablet CPUs to the multi-core behemoths that are today's Sandy Bridge and tomorrow's Ivy Bridge. It just doesn't work that way - look at AMD.

At the end of the day and at this point in time, ARM entering the high-performance desktop sector would be as poorly executed as Intel's foray into the low-energy CPU segment with Atom... except it would suck more.