Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google
by jeroenhd on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:46AM
(#37985556)
Google made the situation a bit harder for themselves with their info boxes (that just repeat the first result, but in an authoritative Google voice) but the "secondary publisher" argument used in the lawsuit makes sense to me.
They weren't required to know the truth from the get go, but they had to remove the libel on notice. Perhaps Google disagreed that there was anything wrong with the assertion that this person was a stalker, but that's a rather risky position to take without any criminal convictions to base their claim off, and a stupid one from a business sense.
Furthermore, their autocomplete is entirely their product, you can't go after anyone else for that.
I imagine this approach wouldn't work in other countries, but if the lawsuit really was baseless in Australia, Google would've won a long time ago, rather than settle now.
They weren't required to know the truth from the get go, but they had to remove the libel on notice. Perhaps Google disagreed that there was anything wrong with the assertion that this person was a stalker, but that's a rather risky position to take without any criminal convictions to base their claim off, and a stupid one from a business sense.
Furthermore, their autocomplete is entirely their product, you can't go after anyone else for that.
I imagine this approach wouldn't work in other countries, but if the lawsuit really was baseless in Australia, Google would've won a long time ago, rather than settle now.