You might be on to something.
I have odd notions of 'exciting' I guess.
Adding the MMO element ... a warship depends on top-down control. The captain gives orders, and a lot of which involve turning valves, pushing buttons, watching screens. Hours pass ...
Okay - make the job exciting so players stick around. So when the captain says 'fire torpedo' there is a player there to load it up.
Sure it can be done, but how? A small fortune to the fellow who figures it out, I guess.
http://yppedia.puzzlepirates.com/Puzzle#Duty_Puzzles
Would this work in an environment that was attempting to be more realistic - probably not - but I am sure a similar dynamic could be used to make a task interesting. This is after all intended to be on star-ships well in the future.
For example, I've long wanted a submarine and/or battleship simulation that would provide a true feeling of being part of a huge ship, with players assuming various roles as necessary. Add a MMO element and it'd be just amazing.