Re:The byte order fallacy
by masklinn on Wednesday April 04, 2012 @02:56AM
(#3796484)
> I wish there were, in C, some equivalent of "struct" but where you could specify
I don't think there's a need for a struct-equivalent, I think there's a need for a struct loader with these capabilities, it would only be in charge of packing and unpacking but would shove everything in a struct.
Basically, Erlang's bit syntax for C (thought the bit syntax unpack to locals, not structs):
<< Foo:16/little, Bar:12/signed, Baz:4 >> = Bin.
(default type specifications are integer, unsigned and big-endian, between the : and / is the size of the data in "units", where Unit defaults to 8 bits for the binary type and 1 bit for integers, floats and strings).
Doesn't natively do alignment though, the developer has to pad on his own.
Python's `struct` module is similar[0]: http://docs.python.org/library/struct.html although the format string is basically unreadable and I believe it's absolutely terrible at decoding non-standard sizes (e.g. an int stored on 3 bits)
[0] libpack[1] for C, Perl also has this[2] which was probably the inspiration for Python
I don't think there's a need for a struct-equivalent, I think there's a need for a struct loader with these capabilities, it would only be in charge of packing and unpacking but would shove everything in a struct.
Basically, Erlang's bit syntax for C (thought the bit syntax unpack to locals, not structs):
(default type specifications are integer, unsigned and big-endian, between the : and / is the size of the data in "units", where Unit defaults to 8 bits for the binary type and 1 bit for integers, floats and strings).Doesn't natively do alignment though, the developer has to pad on his own.
Python's `struct` module is similar[0]: http://docs.python.org/library/struct.html although the format string is basically unreadable and I believe it's absolutely terrible at decoding non-standard sizes (e.g. an int stored on 3 bits)
[0] libpack[1] for C, Perl also has this[2] which was probably the inspiration for Python
[1] http://www.leonerd.org.uk/code/libpack/intro.html
[2] http://perldoc.perl.org/functions/unpack.html