News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by keiferski on Friday October 20, 2023 @11:53PM (#37963935)
I rewatched Blade Runner yesterday and I don’t think I could disagree more. If anything, films from the 80s like BR were far more impressive and well made than anything coming out today. The level of minute details, background sounds, interesting lighting, etc. etc. is levels beyond any big budget film from the last decade.

Every time I watch something like the more recent 2049 BR or Dune films, I’m struck by how empty and boring it all feels. Everything today is too polished, too streamlined. It’s not organic or natural feeling at all.

Here are two clips to compare. The more recent film is typical of movies today: too digital, too clean, not enough movement or energy.

Original Blade Runner: https://youtu.be/vbRRL7S2Tg0?si=gwMJvEr8fj11vUkU

2049: https://youtu.be/opDlMeqRACI?si=Eu2SCx7F_s4lvXLx

Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by stoneforger on Saturday October 21, 2023 @12:59AM (#37964233)
Both films you mention are from Dennis Villeneuve, it's probably just his stylistic look and cinematography in general that you don't like. There are much better examples of bad cinema to contrast against Blade Runner, plus there's not a lot of neonoir.
Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by keiferski on Saturday October 21, 2023 @01:10AM (#37964265)
I’m aware both are by the same director, and I used them as examples of modern style as a whole. It’s not merely his stylistic look.
Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by AlotOfReading on Saturday October 21, 2023 @02:34AM (#37964598)
What other directors do you think look like him? I actually like his style, so more would be great.

It's essentially cinematic brutalism, which I think is perfect for stories like blade runner and Dune. The intimating and oppressive environments do a great job visually communicating the dystopian societies to the viewer.

Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by keiferski on Saturday October 21, 2023 @03:29AM (#37964833)
I think you'd have a difficult time distinguishing his films from most other sci-fi films made today. It's minimal, overly digital, lacking in atmosphere or "dirtiness" that gave so many 80s films their atmosphere. Just watch Escape from New York, or Blade Runner, or The Fifth Element and compare them to something made today.
Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by Terr_ on Saturday October 21, 2023 @02:56AM (#37964704)
> films from the 80s like BR

There's a lot of time between 1980 and now, but I think The Fifth Element (1997) maybe a useful data point when it comes to little details in sci-fi.

For example, when Dallas is at home having a cigarette, and the "filter" portion is bigger than the rest of it.

Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by stickfigure on Saturday October 21, 2023 @03:14AM (#37964768)
Both of those scenes are wonderful in their own way. What is your issue?

I do notice that high-resolution, high-framerate digital images have to work a lot harder than film to look realistic. I'm not sure this is a fair comparison.

Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by corethree on Saturday October 21, 2023 @03:51AM (#37964929)
That's because nostalgia warps your perception of reality.

Let's say you never watched either movie and you were born in the 2000s.

2049 is obviously the superior movie.

Likely you were around when the original blade runner came out so your bias is already set.

Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by keiferski on Saturday October 21, 2023 @04:07AM (#37964992)
I wasn't alive in the 80s, so it's definitely not nostalgia.
Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by arnaudvalette on Saturday October 21, 2023 @06:24AM (#37965581)
I don't understand how you seem to have no problem to say "2049 is obviously the superior movie". In the end your opinion is still an opinion, and your opinions warps your perception of reality. I prefer the vibrant, dusty, chaotic mood of the first one rather than the minimalistic and controlled approach of the second. The town is much more interesting to me in the first than in the second movie, and that's not due to nostalgia.

I frankly find the idea that nostalgia is warping your perception of reality to be funny; aren't your tastes doing the same, and what about your whole brain ?

We are talking about a cultural entity, it's not like if we had the ability to talk without any bias.

Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by corethree on Saturday October 21, 2023 @11:23AM (#37967562)
I would say the majority of people who are younger when given the opportunity to watch both will share the same opinion as me.

It could be my perception is warped. All humans are biased and delusional but those who can't admit their bias are more biased then those who can.

>I frankly find the idea that nostalgia is warping your perception of reality to be funny; aren't your tastes doing the same, and what about your whole brain ?

Just talk to a bunch of young people. You realize a ton of zoomers don't give a shit about star wars? They really don't get it at all. Millennials all generally get why it's big.

Go even further back talk to older people and they like stuff that's ludicrously bad. Hitchcock for example while classic, has not aged well at all. I get scared easily by scary movies and I just laughed at Hitchcock stuff. It was the first of it's time, but story telling like technology has improved.

If you find all of this funny. If you refuse to believe that we all can have our perceptions warped by nostalgia, then I am telling you. The warping of your perception by nostalgia is so strong that you can't even admit that this phenomenon which is so obvious to most people even occurs.

Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by arnaudvalette on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @06:56AM (#37997232)
You didn't understand me properly/something was elliptical in what I said.

I am not refusing to believe our perceptions can be warped by nostalgia. I said that our perception was warped anyway and I explained why "X is obviously the better movie" is a nonsense sentence.

That's absurd to imply I am nostalgic about a movie made about 20 years before I was born, even I prefer that one to the new one.

I continue to prefer that one over the new one even when I know more people of my age prefer the new one.

When you say "Hitchcock has not adged well at all" (which I disagree), aren't you simply telling that you are unable to enjoy things that are not a part of a current story-telling/technology "trend" ?

I do enjoy old things mainly because it brings some sort of fresh breeze to the current aesthetics of cinema. Old things are new to me.

One of my favorite musical composition of all time was written about 300 year ago; implying by this that my mind is warped by nostalgia and that I'm biased is pure nonsense.

Music has changed, but I reject the idea you implied that this change is an " improvement"; I don't think art is improvable stricto-sensus.

Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by corethree on Thursday October 26, 2023 @12:43AM (#38021680)
There's a term for your peer group. Young people who like old stuff. Do you listen to vinyl records as well? The term is "hipster". I don't know if that words is widely used anymore.
Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by arnaudvalette on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @07:07AM (#37997333)
Also, for having watched star wars recently I must say that I "don't give a shit about [it]". I don't think my age has something to do with it.
Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by expensive_news on Saturday October 21, 2023 @09:48AM (#37966762)
Why do you say that “2049 is obviously the superior movie”? You don’t give any reasoning, so I can only assume that you’re implying newer=better?

Is The Batman (2022) obviously superior to The Dark Knight?

(I was not alive in the 80s and love both Blade Runners, but would probably give the edge to the original if I had to choose my favorite. I greatly prefer TDK to TB, but that could be influenced by nostalgia)

Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by corethree on Saturday October 21, 2023 @11:16AM (#37967504)
It's superior because the technology for filming and effects is exponentially superior. Also story telling has become superior... Pacing is something directors pay more attention to and story formats are constantly imitated and improved upon.

The gap between 2022 batman and tdk is too small. When star wars came out it was relevant for over a decade.

Additionally it's impossible for things to increase and become "better" forever. In the last two decades we have are heading towards slow downs in improvements. For example Photoreal special effects can't get any better than Photoreal.

You give the edge to the original? Do you like older movies in general? Do you like vinyl records even though Spotify is superior? Then you belong to a segment of the population who hates everything mainstream because it's too popular. The more niche something is the more you like it because you think it makes you unique when I ironically it makes you cliche.

That could be you. Barring that then you just have unique tastes for br. What I talk about is more of a generality here. It doesn't account for deviations too far from the bell curve, unless your goal is to deviate from the bell curve as much as possible. Ironically if that is your goal, as I stated previously, then you're just moving closer to the center as a hipster.

Re:Blade Runner: The Unofficial White Dragon Cut by gcanyon on Saturday October 21, 2023 @11:40AM (#37967697)
I don't know how I knew, but as soon as I saw the links, I knew I was going to hear the words "He say you blade runner."

Although I'm a fan of the voiceover version, so I also expected, "Sushi. Cold fish. That's what my wife used to call me."

So partial credit for me.