Re:Encrypted traffic interception on Hetzner and Linode targ...
by hlandau on Friday October 20, 2023 @07:37PM
(#37962690)
Both you and the grandparent are correct in that both propose viable attacks; it is a known fact (and not news to any expert in the space) that "domain validation" certificates are vulnerable to "global" MitM in which an attacker can intercept all traffic to a domain (and therefore intercept the validation probes). A situation in which a service's hosting company is sitting on their "front door" (so to speak) and MitMing all traffic that goes their way is exactly such a situation (hence my recommended mitigation).
Re:Encrypted traffic interception on Hetzner and Linode targ...
by codedokode on Friday October 20, 2023 @07:41PM
(#37962707)
Hosting company is not the only one who can do MitM; any ISP through which the traffic passes can do that as well; and if there are backdoors in foreign network equipment then the manufacturer of equipment can do MitM too.
Re:Encrypted traffic interception on Hetzner and Linode targ...
by supriyo-biswas on Friday October 20, 2023 @09:49PM
(#37963388)
This is false, because Let’s Encrypt uses servers in multiple places to get a mix of routing paths to eliminate it as an attack vector.
Re:Encrypted traffic interception on Hetzner and Linode targ...
by codedokode on Friday October 20, 2023 @07:39PM
(#37962699)
ns2.jabber.ru is hosted at Akado (ordinary Russian ISP) in Moscow, as for ns1.jabber.ru it looks like it is hosted at Linode. So maybe ns1 was compromised as well, as for ns2 I doubt that.
Re:Encrypted traffic interception on Hetzner and Linode targ...
by asdfv09s9d80fu9 on Friday October 20, 2023 @08:29PM
(#37962995)
So because one is hosted in Moscow, you find it less likely to be hacked? What a humorous conclusion.
Re:Encrypted traffic interception on Hetzner and Linode targ...
by codedokode on Friday October 20, 2023 @08:51PM
(#37963127)
Yes, because it is highly unlikely that Russian police or Russian ISP will cooperate with US or European police.
the information available right now are too vague to come to a conclusion this bold.
Instead, I find it something like the following more plausible:
jabber.ru and xmpp.ru seem to use "exotic" DNS servers (at least as I checked right now).
https://uk.godaddy.com/whois/results.aspx?itc=dlp_domain_who...
All it then takes is an exploit there in the DNS server, or a badly set-up ACME DNS-01 there, in order for Let's Encrypt to grant an SSL certificate.
https://letsencrypt.org/docs/challenge-types/#dns-01-challen...
The moment you're able to write a (TXT) record for some domain name, you have proven to be eligible for getting an SSL certificate for that domain name.