Re:Body Mass Index Underestimates Obesity Prevalence
by paulsutter on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @05:21PM
(#3794877)
The formula for BMI is simply wrong. It's based on a square of the height. This would be great if we were two dimensional, but we're three dimensional.
Tall people routinely have high BMIs and short people have low BMIs. I'm 6'5", and though I am at the 20th percentile of weight for people of my height, I have a BMI that indicates borderline obesity. And I'm skinny with about 12% bodyfat.
It's just a weird measure. I'm not sure why anyone uses it.
Re:Body Mass Index Underestimates Obesity Prevalence
by artsrc on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @09:39PM
(#3795777)
Since obesity does not matter, who cares what measure you use?
"when we look at objectively measured fitness determined by a maximal exercise test on a treadmill and objectively determined body composition, not self reported height and weight, or not even just body mass index but hydrostatic weighing to estimate percent fat, skin folds, waist circumference, we look at all of those things and the conclusion we come to again and again is that it is low fitness that is a much more important predictor of mortality than is body mass index, fat distribution, overall percent body fat."
"In our analyses over and over again fitness wipes out the hazard associated with obesity."
Re:Body Mass Index Underestimates Obesity Prevalence
by superprime on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @05:19PM
(#3794869)
it's sloppy the other way around too. you can have low body fat and still have high BMI.
i'm more muscular than average but have pretty low body fat (consistently <14%). but because of the BMI calculation I'll often get told I should lose weight when I get a checkup (unless they have half a brain and look before they speak).
Tall people routinely have high BMIs and short people have low BMIs. I'm 6'5", and though I am at the 20th percentile of weight for people of my height, I have a BMI that indicates borderline obesity. And I'm skinny with about 12% bodyfat.
It's just a weird measure. I'm not sure why anyone uses it.
"when we look at objectively measured fitness determined by a maximal exercise test on a treadmill and objectively determined body composition, not self reported height and weight, or not even just body mass index but hydrostatic weighing to estimate percent fat, skin folds, waist circumference, we look at all of those things and the conclusion we come to again and again is that it is low fitness that is a much more important predictor of mortality than is body mass index, fat distribution, overall percent body fat."
"In our analyses over and over again fitness wipes out the hazard associated with obesity."
http://www.abc.net.au/radionational/programs/healthreport/he...
i'm more muscular than average but have pretty low body fat (consistently <14%). but because of the BMI calculation I'll often get told I should lose weight when I get a checkup (unless they have half a brain and look before they speak).