News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Abolish The Reference Check by rdl on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @03:15PM (#3794335)
I'd probably ignore the mail specifically because of the marketing effort for the blog at the bottom (and would have already been a bit hackle-raised at the attempt to define exceptional as top-10%. One, that's wrong. Two, it's patronizing.)

There is something reasonable related to this, though. Let people recommend with different weightings. Say, a way to say "no, this person is a bozo" without directly saying it.

It's like you could come up with a simple web UI to do this. Assign -1 to "this person is a bozo, avoid", 0 to "I am only doing this out of social obligation", 1 to "weak rec", 2 to "good, competent", 3 to "indeed, far better than average", and 4 to "you are an utter moron if you don't hit this."

Maybe add a comment field at the bottom.

The key is to give the recommender a social out -- they can tell the candidate "yes, I recommended you", even if it was a 0 or 1 (or, in some cases, a -1).

Facebook and Google do "recommend" (no-op) vs. "strongly recommend" (actually significant), but adding more levels is good.

There are no comments on this comment yet.