Re:Everything's Made Up and The Points Don't Matter - raganw...
by saurik on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @05:07PM
(#3794831)
In my experience, it has not been possible to predict the audience of such things ahead of time: in fact, it is the things where the most audience-specific assumptions are made that end up (I believe due to those specific assumptions) ending up in the most surprising and irritating of places.
Perhaps one in a hundred or even thousand people reading it might have thought it was real.
But once it escaped our cozy little echo-chamber, it went to a place where many people thought it was real. They aren’t part of a culture that expects parables and satire. They have no familiarity with my existing blow-hardiness on the subject of hiring programmers or privacy. It’s not as reasonable for me to expect that J. Random Facebookfriend will read it and assume it’s a parable.
So, it seemed like the right thing to do to issue a clarification.
tl;dr: An item on the front page of HN doesn’t need a clarification, an item on the front page of Reddit does.