News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lab Leak Fight Casts Chill over Virology Research by cbsmith on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @05:11PM (#37921625)
NIMBYism isn't exactly a good measure of whether something should or shouldn't be done.
Re:Lab Leak Fight Casts Chill over Virology Research by improv on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @05:29PM (#37921861)
NIMBYism != People being concerned about their neighbors possessing weapons of mass destruction/super viruses capable of killing them and millions/billions of other people.
Re:Lab Leak Fight Casts Chill over Virology Research by cbsmith on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @06:58PM (#37922687)
No, but it does equal a people being concerned about the effects of making a change while completely ignoring the effects of NOT making a change.
Re:Lab Leak Fight Casts Chill over Virology Research by improv on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @01:00PM (#37931486)
>while completely ignoring the effects of NOT making a change

The completely hypothetical effects of not making a change in just one area of virology research which is highly criticized by many in the scientific community.

It's hilariously absurd to compare people who don't want a dual use bioweapons research facility in their neighborhood to NIMBYism.

Re:Lab Leak Fight Casts Chill over Virology Research by diogenes4 on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @05:59PM (#37922185)
Please do not conflate people concerned about epidemics with narcissistic assholes.
Re:Lab Leak Fight Casts Chill over Virology Research by cbsmith on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @06:57PM (#37922676)
Describing NIMBYism as "narcissistic assholes" is a gross oversimplification, and misses the point I'm getting at.

In the US, you'll reliably get a lot more NIMBY response from "set up a nuclear power plant in the neighbourhood" vs. "set up a gas power plant in the neighbourhood". However, if you look at the risk assessment, the gas power plant is far more lethal to the neighbourhood.

Re:Lab Leak Fight Casts Chill over Virology Research by diogenes4 on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @07:58PM (#37923189)
> you'll reliably get a lot more NIMBY response from "set up a nuclear power plant in the neighbourhood" vs. "set up a gas power plant in the neighbourhood"

I don't associate the term "NIMBY" with either scenarios, just housing. I don't think there's much value to overloading it. It's not like anyone's trying to put a nuclear power plant in the middle of Boston to begin with.

Re:Lab Leak Fight Casts Chill over Virology Research by cbsmith on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @08:29PM (#37923422)
> I don't associate the term "NIMBY" with either scenarios, just housing.

You might not, but the broader population associates NIMBY with any scenario where a neighbourhood pushes back against some kind of change in that neighbourhood (adding a prison, a power plant, a half-way house, a school, a bar, trains, airports, etc.). There are NIMBY responses to pretty much any change, and the magnitude of that response tends to have little bearing on the relative merits of the change.

> It's not like anyone's trying to put a nuclear power plant in the middle of Boston to begin with.

No. For the most part no one is putting nuclear power plants anywhere in the US. However, there are other power plants in Boston (and for good reason). This is a direct byproduct of the NIMBYism I'm talking about.