There was a time I wished I had gone to HBS or Stanford GSB. While those remain fine institutions, wouldn't any young nerd today prefer YC?
No; it's not a school, and it's for entrepreneurs, not businessmen, which is the heart of the distinction I made previously.
> And wouldn't it be interesting to do a comparative ranking alongside traditional business schools?
No, because there's no basis of comparison. You can be a successful MBA without ever in your life working for a company with less than 10,000 people or having more than a token amount of equity compensation. Some MBAs prefer it that way.
> There was a time I wished I had gone to HBS or Stanford GSB. While those remain fine institutions, wouldn't any young nerd today prefer YC?
Any "young nerd", as far as I understand the term, would prefer a succession of stable job titles with "engineer" on the end from their first job out of college to retirement to an MBA. Now it turns out most of these engineers can be more valuable as founders, which supports the mission of YC. If it wasn't for the bubble and the social proof surrounding YC it would have never attracted the business-school types and you'd never have this confused association in your head.
Here's the way I view it:
- Look at YC as a transfer function. In go individuals who want to learn how to successfully start a business. Out go many individuals who do indeed succeed starting a business.
- Look at HBS at a transfer function. Difference is that the individuals spend a lot more time inside the black box, do a lot more "makework", usually end up with debt not equity, and fewer of them succeed at starting a business. Still a great institution! And clearly many HBS students want to go work for Goldman Sachs, and go on to have great careers doing so.
I'm just saying that higher ed needs to be reinvented, and that reinvention will necessarily happen in ways that dont look like conventional education. Like YC.
Business schools train you to be an officer aboard a battleship. YC trains you to build yourself a dive bomber and pilot it.