Re:BB(3, 3) is Hard
by neilkk on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @08:19AM
(#37913834)
I think the point here is that it was not known whether all 3,3 halting problems are reducible to trivial Collatz-like problems. Unless someone is able to observe that sligicko's is actually trivial, then this provides a counterexample.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:BB(3, 3) is Hard
by FartyMcFarter on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @08:56AM
(#37914212)
> I think the point here is that it was not known whether all 3,3 halting problems are reducible to trivial Collatz-like problems.
True, but it still isn't known either way. Nothing changed in that regard.
'trivial' isn't a mathematical concept. If no one has shown why this problem is trivial, it isn't trivial.
Re:BB(3, 3) is Hard
by FartyMcFarter on Thursday October 19, 2023 @07:28AM
(#37941353)
This problem isn't trivial, but neither are the ones we could already reduce BB(3, 3) to (via Conway's construction).
Some reductions via Conway's method give non-trivial Collatz problems even though other simple techniques should the halting question for those machines to be trivial; the Conway reduction sometimes reduces trivial Turing machines to non-trivial Collatz problems.