Beyond that, however, the poster needs to learn about ROC curves (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Receiver_operating_characterist...) – for just a moment, let's assume we're genuinely only hiring "A" players – then the challenge is a signal detection problem, pure and simple – sorting the signal from the noise and avoiding both false positives and false negatives.
While I have huge issues with the post's method, it's clearly only focused on avoiding false-positives – avoiding hiring someone who's bad but is sold as good/great. Unfortunately, there are real issues with false negatives as well – you may miss out on a fantastic candidate, first and foremost...
But, of course, decisions aren't that simple. Anyone who understands decision making knows that decisions depend highly on context – including the context provided by the other options... and if you systematically fail to account for eliminating some number of options, you may well be (foolishly) limiting the range of options and the context of your decision. In short, "A players" are relative...
And that idea goes even further. Many stellar employees, innovators, coders, etc. don't start out that way. Sure, some do, but those aren't the people applying and giving you references.
Your job, when hiring from a resume pool, is precisely to find those diamonds in the rough – those false negatives.
Personally I've got to say that I also find the "rock star" rhetoric to be a huge turn-off. When I see it in a job ad I think of how horrible it would be to have to work with a club of self-described "A" players.
The gruelling interviews are another perverse system that I think has a negative effect. If you can easily get lots of interviews are you going to bother with the five stage interview with four hours of quiz questions and "homework"?
That's very true. I browse Linkedin sometimes, and I'm often surprised to find out x# of people have recommended a terrible ex-coworker.
Reference checks, as they exist today, are useless. Doing them as an opt-in email at least gives you a small chance of getting some signal. No, you can't use it to sort them into your A-B-C rock star instant hire buckets.
But it's a signal. Signals are good.
First of all, I'm ready to stab myself in the eye every time I have to see someone they only hire "A" players. This is getting tiresome and unbelievable - I don't know of any startup that has nothing but "A-player type work" to do. Almost every plausible startup has some work that will be comfortably addressed by a range of abilities and the idea that you're going to stuff your startup full of absolute super-stars (and do well as a result) is just posturing.
I am also not entirely sure that someone whose references are, I dunno, busy doing actual work or "on holiday" deserves to be penalized with respect to someone whose references are all hanging around in their office with nothing to do but promote the living shit out of each other in some kind of mutual admiration society.
Speaking from experience, I have seen many such cliques of utterly mediocre, self-serving people who would unhesitatingly tell happy stories of how wonderful everyone in their clique was to anyone who asked - even if a more conventional response from further up the management chain would have given a very tepid review of the actual performance of said people.
Finally, if you're going to contact a bunch of people out of the blue, adding self-promoting line about your blog is not appropriate. Under the signature line, maybe, but putting it the body text is a dick move.