You should already be convinced that the person is exceptional (in talent) or at least good enough to hire before you start messing around with references. The purpose of a reference check is to make sure the person isn't either (a) lying about his background, or (b) seriously harmful. For (b), I don't think references are the solution but I can't think of anything better. Unfortunately, there's no character test that can be done in a few hours of interaction.
I don't know that I've encountered such an ill-conceived idea in quite awhile. Forget all the false negatives this method would be sure to "detect", I wouldn't feel comfortable spamming the candidates contact list.
If we're going to ignore the douchebag baggage ("douchebaggage"? 'tis a new word) associated with "A-player" and "B-player", I'd say I really want the person who turns B-players into A-players.
Maybe it could be improved to be super short and only ask for a simple "yes" answer so they can answer it right away instead of flagging and moving back to it.