Re:France bans all pro-Palestinian demonstrations
by raxxorraxor on Monday October 16, 2023 @05:46AM
(#37897564)
You haven't put forward any argument that would allow for such a severe accusation, so I can dismiss it w.ithout comment just fine.
I am not flexible about the vocabulary of ethnic cleansing for that matter. It has a very specific meaning
Re:France bans all pro-Palestinian demonstrations
by giraffe_lady on Monday October 16, 2023 @09:48AM
(#37899856)
I'm not making an argument, I'm making an assertion that you called a lie. So clearly you understood the point I'm making, I don't see that it requires further litigation on the details.
So, again, what happened? What is your description of the events that led to palestinians being so concentrated in gaza, and no longer living in the land they inhabited before.
Again I am giving you an opportunity to tell this story in the words you prefer. What, other than your cowardice, is preventing you from taking it?
Re:France bans all pro-Palestinian demonstrations
by raxxorraxor on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @01:32AM
(#37910985)
Heh, no, it definitely doesn't need any litigation of the details at all as the case is pretty clear, your honor.
It is their own making. It is safe to be a Palestinian in Israel, while you probably don't want to be a Jew in Gaza.
Re:France bans all pro-Palestinian demonstrations
by giraffe_lady on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @12:53PM
(#37917953)
You wouldn't want to be an unarmed german in an unsupervised corner of auchswitz either but that's hardly a condemnation of the prisoners is it.
Re:France bans all pro-Palestinian demonstrations
by raxxorraxor on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @03:23AM
(#37925760)
That comparison doesn't fit because the Jews in Germany didn't want to exterminate Germans. That was Nazi propaganda. Perhaps that perspective survived from the closeness of Hitler with the Mufti.
> I stand by my statement that the accusation of ethnic cleansing is a hideous lie.
What does it mean "stand by" a statement that an assertion is a lie without attempting to refute the assertion? This is a nonsense action, it is nothing. I said I'm flexible about the vocabulary we use when we talk about what happened, so what happened? Why do so many palestinians live in gaza? Why aren't there more of them in other parts of israel?
I'm giving you an opportunity to describe it on your terms. So describe it.