News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by geon on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:20AM (#37889494)
If I pirate some content, how is that different to them compared to me just not buying it? Should they be allowed to disconnect my internet because I don’t buy their content?

The studios can so easily kill all piracy, and they just about did it with Spotify and Netflix. But no, the greed made them split up into a dozen different services nobody wants, and here we are again.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by awjlogan on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:27AM (#37889537)
Because you are getting something produced by someone for free if you pirate it and you are relying on others to fund your consumption. Take that to the logical extreme: everybody pirates everything. That is _very_ different to everyone not buying it. There is demand for the product and it has a cost to produce. If you steal something from somebody, there is recourse in law.

I don't disagree about the greed part, but I guess fragmentation is almost inevitable until the profit margin is driven down to near zero. Shortsighted, probably, but it would essentially require all the producers to back (and therefore yield profit to), one or two Netflix/Spotify type entities.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by haswell on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:35AM (#37889585)
Taking this to the logical extreme is fallacious. The piracy wars up to this point have already shown that people buy content if it’s reasonably priced, and that piracy in many cases actually increases sales of the original content. The fact that piracy is back in the limelight has everything to do with the failing business models of greedy companies, and is the market reacting accordingly.

The fact that there are penalties for stealing physical goods does not imply that just any penalty is fine. The analogy doesn’t work. Removal of Internet access in 2023 is debilitating. Punishments are supposed to fit the crime, and the complete loss of access to what has become a fundamental point of access does not fit the crime.

And there’s also the very old arguments that I won’t rehash here about the clear difference between digital copies of content and physical items.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by awjlogan on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:42AM (#37889649)
If I don't think a product in the shop is reasonably priced, I don't have the right just to take it. The shop can decide to reduce the price in response to the market - they may make less profit than before and make up for it in volume. However, that is entirely their perogative.

There is zero difference between a digital and physical item if you are the producer. A digital good has the cost of production front loaded, it just has next to zero marginal cost. That may be the cost of education and experience, for example. If you make something of value, you absolutely have the right to choose how you are rewarded - if the buyer decides that choice isn't right for them, you can either change the offer or you look for your next customer. You may choose to give it away, if your reward is the satisfaction of someone using it, but that is your choice, not the consumer's.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by logicchains on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:57AM (#37889763)
>There is zero difference between a digital and physical item if you are the producer

There's absolutely a difference. If you produce a physical good, and somebody takes it, you no longer have it. If you produce a digital good and somebody copies it, you still have the original, you're still free to use and enjoy it as you see fit.

Fundamentally property rights are a negative right: you have the right not to have your stuff taken. Negative rights don't conflict with eachother, that's why they make a good basis for society. Intellectual property is a positive right: you have the right to control how other people use their property, which conflicts with people's right to use their property as they see fit.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by awjlogan on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:04AM (#37889820)
Intellectual property is a response exactly to the difference in the marginal cost because it recognises the threat to the value creating producer. Just because you don't tangibly see the cost of the IP, that doesn't mean it was free to produce.

You can absolutely argue that IP law is cynically applied, but in principle it protects high capital and low operating expense businesses from those who would like to do the low operating expense part without bothering about the high capital part.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by haswell on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:01AM (#37889788)
> If I don't think a product in the shop is reasonably priced, I don't have the right just to take it

We need to collectively stop using these kinds of physical goods analogies in discussions about piracy. To claim that there is no difference is a fundamental miscalculation.

To be clear, I do not condone piracy. I purchase the content that I view. But these kinds of fallacious analogies are misleading and dangerous to Internet freedom.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by awjlogan on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:11AM (#37889876)
In what way is it fallacious? Or dangerous? (That's a genuine question).

Fundamentally, it's the same problem - producers have to adjust their prices to reflect the threat to their income. If I produce something, and I forecast X% of my overall market to be stolen, I have to adjust my selling price according. It doesn't matter if that something is physical or digital.

If I produce something that is digital I have the luxury of being able to reduce the cost as low as I like to capture as much value as I can, but that is still my choice as the producer.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by haswell on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:23AM (#37889977)
These arguments have been rehashed for decades at this point, and I think it’s best that I just link to an overview [0].

The bottom line is it there is a lot of nuance here, and simple analogies that make one act appear to be the same as the other lead to some reductionist conclusions that have been repeatedly taken up by lawmakers who do not understand these nuances.

-[0] https://phys.org/news/2015-04-downloading-ethics-digital-pir...

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by awjlogan on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:30AM (#37890060)
Thank you for the link, appreciate the read and the nuance is important and I don't at all believe in the fundamentalist view on either side. I'm in complete agreement that threatening someone with massive legal ramifications is not good, but I do believe that people who make things of value should be able to do so with proportionate recourse to law to protect their livelihood. Law is, of course, made (or at least moulded) by those with money/influence so weighing the proportionality is the issue.
Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by haswell on Sunday October 15, 2023 @12:37PM (#37891204)
Yeah, I agree. I don’t think people should be free to pirate with impunity, but I get very very uneasy when people trot out life ruining penalties (not saying you’re doing this).

I’ve been transitioning away from a career in tech into creating educational content for a niche I love, and I’m sensitive to the need for recourse. At the same time, I think I’m far less likely as an individual creator to have much recourse because I don’t have a team of lawyers.

This is the other aspect of these piracy discussions that always bothers me. It’s really the behemoths vs. individuals, which to me points at very misaligned thinking when it comes to the resulting policy/laws.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by beej71 on Sunday October 15, 2023 @12:19PM (#37891028)
If you sell a table, I am absolutely free to pirate that table by going home and making a copy of it. Totally legal. Creator gets no money for their work.

Digital goods have far more legal protection against this than physical ones.

They are not the same.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by c22 on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:51AM (#37889719)
People who are convicted of drunk driving are often permitted to drive again (especially if they need to to go to work) but are required to put a breathalyzer interlock on their ignition so they can't drive drunk.

Perhaps similarly, people convicted of internet piracy could be required to operate with their torrent ports blocked, or with some sort of nanny state spyware installed on their devices.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by batch12 on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:24AM (#37889996)
> Perhaps similarly, people convicted of internet piracy could be required to operate with their torrent ports blocked, or with some sort of nanny state spyware installed on their devices.

So we need a pirate registry? And if you're convicted of 'internet piracy' (a term that is an excellent example of propaganda) then you forfeit any rights you have protecting your privacy and shielding you from warrantless government searches. Doesn't sound like an appropriate punishment for the offense to me.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by haswell on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:57AM (#37889761)
People who drive drunk and regain their privileges, do so with restrictions that are meant to protect the people around them. The breathalyzer interlock is made to ensure that this person cannot endanger other people.

I think it’s extremely problematic to compare piracy to drunk driving, and to model a punishment for piracy on the punishment for drunk driving for the reasons stated above.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by c22 on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:12AM (#37889883)
Obviously you have to believe that the behavior causes harm to justify a restriction, but if you don't accept this premise then you cannot have an opinion on what would be an appropriate response because you believe there should be no response.

I'm not trying to take a position on this either way, but within the context of 'internet piracy causes some sort of damage' I don't think the comparison is particularly problematic.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by haswell on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:16AM (#37889920)
Restrictions are not the only form of punishment. Many infractions result in a simple fine. Others in mandatory education, etc.

My point was that comparing this to a crime that kills people by the tens of thousands every year seems very stretched.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by renzobanks on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:12AM (#37889881)
anybody can simply change the ports on which they choose to download a torrent.
Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by c22 on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:14AM (#37889901)
Anyone can disable, bypass, or remove the breathalyzer in their car.
Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by renzobanks on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:10AM (#37889869)
agreed, other than your "Punishments are supposed to fit the crime statement." that's one ideal out of many. I would say that companies that create things that are beneficial for people to learn how to use, but that are prohibitivly expensive for students, and younger people to afford to learn how to use like how Adobe products used to be, should always put systems in place to allow people to obtain free access to their products where that kind of thing is obviously applicable. Things that are meant for consumption (movies, tv shows, music) only should be paid a fair market price for in one way or another by the people that consume it. I say this as a both a member of the music industry and the software development industry.
Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by awjlogan on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:23AM (#37889981)
Do remember that Adobe, say, does not give away their product to students out of the goodness of their heart: they want you to use their product when they start working and ask your employers to shell out the full amount.
Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by shadowgovt on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:40AM (#37889630)
[delayed]
Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by awjlogan on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:56AM (#37889756)
Brutal, but true :/
Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by c22 on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:45AM (#37889669)
The word piracy was obviously chosen to create exactly this sort of confusion, but piracy on the internet is fundamentally different than stealing which is not buying someone's stuff and also depriving them of the ability to sell it to someone else.
Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by awjlogan on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:51AM (#37889716)
You are, instead, "stealing" the means for the producer to make more if they can't afford to do it any more because you've normalised using people's work without compensation. It doesn't really matter if the marginal cost of reproduction is near zero, it is the producer's choice what to price their product at, not yours. You're pushing the cost on to others to subsidise your consumption.
Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by c22 on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:05AM (#37889827)
But now we're getting into a much more nuanced argument about the shape of society. If I, as a lone actor, hook my tape deck into the output of my radio and "steal" the newest Britney Spears track have I normalized the act of piracy?

If everyone is doing it then it does seem pretty normalized, but if everyone is doing it then your presumption as to society's values seems flawed.

In reality these media producers seem to be making healthy profits so perhaps internet piracy is not as normalized as you think.

Re:'Terminating Internet Access over Piracy Claims Is Drasti... by renzobanks on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:16AM (#37889917)
I think the word piracy is worse honestly, because what it really means is to swashbuckle on the open seas. And i don't think stealing physical goods or digital goods is quite comparable to that.