News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Widely Accepted Mathematical Results That Were Later Show... by joewferrara on Saturday October 14, 2023 @05:43PM (#37884521)
It's kind of the opposite scenario (a mathematical result that people are widely skeptical of, but that could be correct), but this reminded me, I wonder what's going on with Mochizuki's proof of the ABC conjecture.
Re:Widely Accepted Mathematical Results That Were Later Show... by jfengel on Saturday October 14, 2023 @05:56PM (#37884613)
The proof situation is pretty much unchanged. The proof uses a very obscure branch of mathematics, so that few people are capable of a real critique. Those few have mostly said that it's not complete, but Mochizuki and a few others disagree.

It's kind of a philosophical question at this point about what actually comprises a valid proof, if other mathematicians can't make use of it.

So the conjecture is still mostly considered unproven. That could change at any point but there have been no real advances in some time.

Re:Widely Accepted Mathematical Results That Were Later Show... by vbezhenar on Saturday October 14, 2023 @06:30PM (#37884844)
Make proof using computer system, obviously.
Re:Widely Accepted Mathematical Results That Were Later Show... by alimw on Saturday October 14, 2023 @07:24PM (#37885213)
Mochizuki is unenthusiastic.

[1] Section 1.12 of https://www.kurims.kyoto-u.ac.jp/~motizuki/Essential%20Logic....

Re:Widely Accepted Mathematical Results That Were Later Show... by eddiewithzato on Saturday October 14, 2023 @06:59PM (#37885039)
everything relies on consensus anyway
Re:Widely Accepted Mathematical Results That Were Later Show... by preommr on Saturday October 14, 2023 @11:08PM (#37886519)
> very obscure branch of mathematics

This is an understatement. He developed a completely different branch of mathematics through papers that spanned hundreds of pages with very dense and very different ideas from mainstream mathematics.

If it was just slightly obscure, maybe all but half a dozen mathematicians in the world might be able to understand his work. As it stands, at it's best, his proof is so opaque that even the brightest (Scholze) can only kind of understand it. At it's worst, they've rightfully identified it as flawed and that even Mochizuki himself doesn't understand that it's wrong.

Re:Widely Accepted Mathematical Results That Were Later Show... by bsder on Sunday October 15, 2023 @12:47AM (#37886964)
> what's going on with Mochizuki's proof of the ABC conjecture.

The assumption at this point is that it's broken.

The onus is on Mochizuki to either clarify the proof or use the tools of the proof on some other already established problem to show their validity.