News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Hallucinating" AIs sound creative, but let's not celebra... by pdonis on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:16PM (#37877800)
> It's like saying "Human brains are just meat".

No, it isn't, because human brains have rich semantic connections to the rest of the world. LLMs do not. So "LLMs are just generating text" is a justified description of their limitations, in a way that "human brains are just meat" is not.

Re:"Hallucinating" AIs sound creative, but let's not celebra... by gaganyaan on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:40PM (#37877898)
> LLMs do not

Prove it

Re:"Hallucinating" AIs sound creative, but let's not celebra... by pdonis on Saturday October 14, 2023 @02:15PM (#37882827)
I don't have to; the people who designed the LLMs have already done so by explicitly describing how they work.

See, for example, my contrast of what an LLM does with what Wolfram Alpha does upthread.

Re:"Hallucinating" AIs sound creative, but let's not celebra... by gaganyaan on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:42PM (#37884095)
Wolfram Alpha has a model of the world manually created by humans. LLMs generate a model of the world from training data. "Explicitly describing" how something works doesn't mean you wave your hands and say "therefore meat is magic".

I have no idea why you think Wolfram Alpha is relevant. LLMs can use tools like langchain to do the exact same thing Wolfram Alpha does. What proof do you have for your original claim?