Thank you for finding this!
Recently I heard someone is trying this again with water heaters. The working fluid has roughly four times the heat capacity of water, so your “water” heater is substantially a fluid heater with either no water tank or a very small one. Incoming water is heated with the fluid, and the fluid is heated on demand. Only the heat exchanger has maintenance concerns.
Driving the whole thing with a heat pump makes the math a little more fiddly, since peak pump efficiency and peak power prices overlap some of the same parts of the day. You’re calculating BTUs per dollar, not watt hours per dollar.
Few households use more than 80 gallons of hot water per day which is still within the normal range of hot water heaters. Just add a timer so it doesn’t kick on until powers cheap and you’ll be good to go. At least assuming your cheap electricity window is long enough to fully heat the water.
This is one of the reasons people overestimate the need for grid energy storage. People time shift electricity to the night because it’s cheap. If it was cheaper 10AM-4PM then significant demand would shift to that window.
Sounds like we would need “smart” water heaters that can query energy prices. That most likely means they would be online sharing all kinds of data most of us probably don’t want shared and would have a small monthly fee. The water heater might even be very inexpensive because of this.
I know it wouldn’t have to be implemented this way, but of course that’s how it would go.
These days, rates can be more flexible thanks to "smart" meters (communicating via PLC). Just after the russian invasion of Ukraine, there were plans in place to open the dry contacts of customers outside of the scheduled hours in case the electricity grid needed to shed extra load. Thankfully this didn't end up being necessary.
What I'm saying is that you don't really require smart end devices. Put the incentives in place (deep discounts) and the rest will follow. You probably need at least one smart device to control the others if a timer is not enough, and I think the electricity meter is a good fit for that role.
I dont think much else even comes close
[1] Table 4, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/231542196_Heat_Capa...
Paraffin is 2.1 Kj/whatever
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/336006577_Comparing...
Phase change seems to work better for trying to maintain an ambient temperature. The input side is always going to be cold, and at some times of year far colder than others.
Tangent: Startup Andora Energy claims to have solved the maintenance problem by using carbon bricks. Also, apparently elemental carbon is capable of holding even more as it heats up (to a point).
Further: Their next gen product plans to use infrared wave length voltaics (name?), converting heat directly into electricity. That'd be spiffy.
TLDR: Novel liquid desiccant functions as a "humidity battery" (my phrase). A salt solution which captures and releases moisture. It's closed loop and doesn't need to be replenished. Claimed OpEx $/hWh (for just the dehumidifier) is ~ $20/hWh, vs > $600 for Li-ion and ~ $400 for ice thermal based systems. It's safer and more durable.
Liquid Desiccants as Breakthrough Energy Storage [2021] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2SwMyGzXsuE
Liquid Desiccants and Our Cooling Process - Blue Frontier, LLC [2021] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8B4LQTQ94g
https://bluefrontierac.com
"At Blue Frontier, our mission is to transform buildings into sustainable, comfortable, and interactive spaces. Our first step towards achieving this goal is the commercialization of a revolutionary air conditioning technology. Blue Frontier’s AC system combines dew-point-style sensible cooling with liquid desiccant dehumidification to reduce electricity use by up to 90% (non-fan). The desiccant is recharged and stored when electricity is the cleanest or lowest cost, and later used to deliver cooling when electricity is dirty or costly. These features enable our system to solve an array of today’s largest sustainability problems — from the Duck Curve to peak load management, from humidity control to integration of intermittent renewable resources."
Note the "Duck Curve" bit. Their "humidity battery" (my phrase) allows them to do load shifting. In the actual AC unit(s).
That's really bitchin'.