News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tainting the CSAM client-side scanning database by Chabsff on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:47AM (#37871912)
You may think that intuitively, but actual studies actually indicate the opposite. Usage of CSAM material leads to increased risks of contacting and abusing children.

This needs to be balanced against rights to privacy and expression, which I personally think take precedence, but pretending that it can serve as harm reduction is just not correct.

Re:Tainting the CSAM client-side scanning database by qingcharles on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:17PM (#37872230)
There are so few actual studies of this, and AI images being only a year or so old, that I would not put any weight behind them at this point.

My point isn't that AI CSAM should be legal or not, but whether these tools can differentiate what the lawmakers have decided is a crime or not.

Re:Tainting the CSAM client-side scanning database by chatmasta on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:58AM (#37872040)
I'm personally highly skeptical of the "offering them an outlet" argument. I'd be less suspicious of the idea if its proponents also suggested limiting it to controlled settings, e.g. during meetings with a professional psychiatrist.

But I'm sorry, I just don't believe anyone holed up in their room with a bunch of fake CSAM is "just using it as an outlet" or "protecting real kids from harm." I mean, it almost sounds like a threat: "If you don't let me look at these pictures of fake kids, I'll hurt real kids." If that's the case then they should be seeing a psychiatrist, at minimum.

Re:Tainting the CSAM client-side scanning database by LorenPechtel on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:23PM (#37876270)
Pornography reduces rape.

Violent movies that appeal to teens reduce vandalism and the like--they're in the theater rather than out causing trouble. (And it's not displaced, rates don't spike later, they just return to normal.)

Re:Tainting the CSAM client-side scanning database by chatmasta on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:32PM (#37877052)
Citation needed.
Re:Tainting the CSAM client-side scanning database by callalex on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:12PM (#37872947)
Studies such as?
Re:Tainting the CSAM client-side scanning database by LorenPechtel on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:21PM (#37876257)
Of course it's related. That doesn't mean it "leads to"--I think that's a case of the cart before the horse.

Those who have no sexual interest in children are neither going to have CSAM nor engage in abuse. The fact that they had CSAM already shows it's a highly non-random sample. The control would be pedophiles with no access to CSAM--but how do you find that control group????