News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by runako on Thursday October 12, 2023 @02:38PM (#37861154)
> I don't understand how this is legal.

It's presumably laid out in the contract that their users sign. IANAL but I understand contract law gives wide latitude for parties to make agreements to do things which are generally legal.

One could imagine a legal regime that prohibited price or service changes in otherwise-legal contracts. Of course, that also might not be ideal. For example: a vendor used by the provider suddenly changes the capabilities of a piece of equipment such that the original service sold by the provider can no longer be provided at any price. What everybody wants in that scenario is for you to be seamlessly moved to the closest reasonable alternative, not for your service to automatically terminate. Similarly, most people will gripe about a $10/mo change in price, but against the likely alternative of automatic cancellation, the increased fee is what _most_ people will prefer.

And again, 100% of them will have agreed to this exception-handling clause when they signed up.

Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by crazygringo on Thursday October 12, 2023 @02:45PM (#37861248)
But contact law also strikes down contact provisions all the time.

Generally speaking, contracts between two parties who know what they're doing, with lawyers, are pretty iron-clad.

But TOS with consumers are not. Unreasonable/abusive TOS clauses are struck down quite frequently. Things like consumer protection laws supersede anything in a TOS.

And consumer protection laws are precisely the kind of thing meant to stop companies from playing bait-and-switch with consumers like this.

Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by pazimzadeh on Thursday October 12, 2023 @03:37PM (#37862075)
Can you share cases where TOS with consumers was struck down? Thanks very much.
Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by dawnerd on Thursday October 12, 2023 @03:01PM (#37861537)
A lot of these older plans were marketed as no contract plans. That was tmobiles whole thing for a while. No more contracts. Obviously there still is via terms and such but it’s a pretty gray area I’m sure lawyers would be willing to argue in court. They also claimed prices would never go up (on your plan).
Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by cmeacham98 on Thursday October 12, 2023 @03:43PM (#37862171)
"No contract" in the telco world means no minimum length clauses (as opposed to something like a "12 month contract" plan, where you legally agree to stay on the plan for at least one year), it doesn't literally mean there isn't a contract.
Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by arcticbull on Thursday October 12, 2023 @04:52PM (#37863028)
Right but in the same way I can end the contract and walk away at any time, I would imagine it's totally kosher for T-Mobile to do the same. It's not like either party is locked in.
Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by cmeacham98 on Thursday October 12, 2023 @05:18PM (#37863278)
Sure, but "end the contract" doesn't mean "upgrade to a higher paying plan without consent".
Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by arcticbull on Thursday October 12, 2023 @08:01PM (#37864751)
I mean I can change to a more or less expensive plan by giving the carrier notice, I assume its fair for the carrier to do the same to me no? If you want to guarantee a price plan, sign a term contract.

Feels like customers want to have their cake and eat it: lock the carrier in, but have no obligations of their own.

Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by thunky on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:36PM (#37865484)
> I can change to a more or less expensive plan by giving the carrier notice, I assume its fair for the carrier to do the same to me no?

No.

Would you feel the same if the landlord of your month-to-month rental upgraded you to a more expensive house?

Sure they can increase the rent, and you can move somewhere else, but there is baseline a expectation that the house you rented will not change.

Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by arcticbull on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:32PM (#37865858)
> Would you feel the same if the landlord of your month-to-month rental upgraded you to a more expensive house?

I mean, if they renovated my unit or even the common areas, and told me I could stay at a higher rent I'd think that was just fine. It happened to me at least once already, come to think of it.

But yeah, they raised the rent on people without term commitments effective immediately, and anyone on a term contract could keep their old rate until it expired.

Again if you don't like the risk of this changing out from under you, sign a term contract, right?

Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by thunky on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:40AM (#37869921)
I'm not saying they raise the rent on your current place (which is perfectly fine), I'm saying they move/upgrade you to a more expensive address that you've never seen before.
Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by dawnerd on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:09PM (#37877214)
I mean we know this but do you think the average consumer knows this? They’re still locking people in two two year plans by use of the whole “free phone” or “upgrade” offers.
Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by runako on Thursday October 12, 2023 @02:51PM (#37861360)
Absolutely agree re: abusive TOS clauses. My question is this: if you were on a panel evaluating whether it's more abusive to a) migrate customers to a plan that's $10 more or b) end their service because the vendor no longer offers that service, which would you vote for?

Note that consumer panels will have less ability to force a vendor to set prices or provide specific services, so there will not be the third option of c) force the vendor to continue providing the service at the contracted price.

Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by hef19898 on Thursday October 12, 2023 @02:59PM (#37861492)
That's why in Europe abusive and surprising (to an informed party) terms and condiations are invalid. Quite aome legal disputes around those so.
Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by runako on Thursday October 12, 2023 @03:32PM (#37861996)
Curious -- how do services raise prices? Is the presumption that a carrier has to give notice, then the user has to opt in or their service automatically terminates?

> in Europe abusive and surprising (to an informed party) terms and condiations

It can't be surprising to any informed party that prices change. Especially right now, it cannot be argued in good faith that a price increase was surprising to anyone.

Does the user have to opt in each time the service changes (for ex if 2G service gets dropped)? Who decides what requires a user approval?

Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by flarg on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:13AM (#37866580)
In the EU they send a letter informing of price change and give you the right of cancellation except for rate rises in line with the retail price index or inflation which are included in the contract. Truly fixed price contracts are advertised as such, I have one for my broadband, can only be withdrawn by the vendor.
Re:T-Mobile switching users to more expensive plans unless t... by sdossick on Thursday October 12, 2023 @06:14PM (#37863865)
If the user has changed phones (even keeping the same number) or has for instance begun using 5G (which wasn't available 5 years ago...tmo started rolling it out at the tail end of 2019), they're using a materially different product than they were originally contracted for, and have likely agreed to new terms. Not saying that isn't scammy or scummy, but just like you've changed the product you're using, they can change the product they're selling.