Re:Bentham's Mugging (2022)
by slibhb on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:19AM
(#37858427)
The mugger cuts off his own fingers when a different utilitarian doesn't pay him. Given that, and given that he's right back at it after surgery, I don't think it's so clear that he'll "respond to incentives" and stop mugging people if people stop giving in.
After all, one of the premises here is that the mugger is a deontologist. He doesn't care about outcomes.
After all, one of the premises here is that the mugger is a deontologist. He doesn't care about outcomes.