News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by Shekelphile on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @07:52PM (#37839268)
Source 2 already has rendering backends for d3d9, 11, opengl and vulkan. There's no reason why they can't support metal besides a refusal to task someone to it.
Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by littlestymaar on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @08:05PM (#37839372)
Lack of users means lack of budget to pay for the said “someone”.

Also, there's no reason why Apple can't support OpenGL properly either, there “no reason besides the refusal to task someone to it”.

Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by Shekelphile on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @08:11PM (#37839425)
> Also, there's no reason why Apple can't support OpenGL properly either, there “no reason besides the refusal to task someone to it”.

They do. OpenGL is deprecated, but still supported. If it wasn't supported at all it would not have worked on apple silicon macs.

Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by littlestymaar on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @08:42PM (#37839638)
Note that I said “supported properly” above. In addition to the very high number of bugs in Apple's implementation, the fact that it is officially deprecated sends a message to anyone wanting to do new development on MacOS “don't invest in OpenGL now as we could pull the rug under your feet” and it's done on purpose to push developers to Metal.

So now they can only blame themselves if they're losing games because the developer doesn't want to invest in Metal either.

Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by Shekelphile on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @09:11PM (#37839812)
> In addition to the very high number of bugs in Apple's implementation

Many of those 'bugs' remain unfixed to maintain backwards compatibility, not because Apple doesn't want to fix them.

> the fact that it is officially deprecated sends a message to anyone wanting to do new development on MacOS “don't invest in OpenGL now as we could pull the rug under your feet” and it's done on purpose to push developers to Metal.

As it should be.

> So now they can only blame themselves if they're losing games because the developer doesn't want to invest in Metal either.

There's nothing to 'invest' in. Metal is by far the simplest low level graphics API out of all I've used and it would not be hard for valve to write a source 2 rendering backend for it (few days/weeks at most for an experienced dev). There's plenty of AAA games being properly ported to apple silicon now and in a year or two there will be many more. Valve intentionally withdrawing themselves from the ecosystem is purely out of spite.

Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by phone8675309 on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @10:33PM (#37840256)
> it would not be hard for valve to write a source 2 rendering backend for it (few days/weeks at most for an experienced dev).

Put your money where your mouth is and write one. Just write one. If it's that easy, do it.

Which is more likely - a company that dumps tons and tons of resources into Linux, Wine, DXVK, and put out the Steam deck didn't do this supposedly easy thing because they just don't care or could it be that they don't have the talent in house and wouldn't recoup their investment by doing it?

Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by Shekelphile on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @11:00PM (#37840395)
> Put your money where your mouth is and write one. Just write one. If it's that easy, do it.

I can't because source 2's source code isn't available.

> Which is more likely - a company that dumps tons and tons of resources into Linux, Wine, DXVK, and put out the Steam deck didn't do this supposedly easy thing because they just don't care or could it be that they don't have the talent in house and wouldn't recoup their investment by doing it?

They don't have the talent? That's funny, considering Valve ported all their games to macOS many years before they ported to linux.

Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by phone8675309 on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @01:16AM (#37841151)
> I can't because source 2's source code isn't available.

Perhaps then refrain from telling everyone how easy it as when you have no idea what’s going on in the code.

> That's funny, considering Valve ported all their games to macOS many years before they ported to linux.

Are those people still at the company? Either they are not or they’re doing a piss poor job at advocating for their platform.

Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by Shekelphile on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @02:00AM (#37841422)
> Perhaps then refrain from telling everyone how easy it as when you have no idea what’s going on in the code.

I've been reverse engineering source engine games and modding them on and off for the last ~15 years, I almost certainly know more about it than you.

Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by littlestymaar on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @03:10AM (#37841789)
> I've been reverse engineering source engine games and modding them on and off for the last ~15 years

> I can't because source 2's source code isn't available.

No contradiction at all here…

Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by Shekelphile on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @01:42PM (#37847715)
Source code for source 1 has been available for 20 years. It's been fully leaked multiple times and an official SDK with limited source is also available. There is no contradiction.
Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by littlestymaar on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @03:20AM (#37841827)
> They don't have the talent? That's funny, considering Valve ported all their games to macOS many years before they ported to linux.

Using OpenGL, not metal, thought. There's a good chance that they don't have a single developer knowing metal.

Sure they could learn, but then there's the next part of the sentence you're responding to: it's unlikely they wouldn't recoup their investment by doing it.

Re:Valve Says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS Not Happening, Ther... by littlestymaar on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @03:07AM (#37841779)
> Many of those 'bugs' remain unfixed to maintain backwards compatibility, not because Apple doesn't want to fix them.

Backward compatible kernel panics is a interesting idea for sure…

> As it should be.

Can't complain if Valve don't follow them on that then.

> There's nothing to 'invest' in. Metal is by far the simplest low level graphics API

That doesn't change the fact that porting the game engine to it is still a massive undertaking. It doesn't depend on the graphic API itself that much, but more about the size and complexity of the rendering engine.

Valve isn't stupid, if it was profitable to do so, they'd do the investment anyway, but do not because it doesn't make financial sense.

Apple isn't entitled a free port of popular games to their walled garden. Developers may do it if it's profitable, but that's it. If Apple wants to bootstrap the gaming use case, then it's on them to make an effort.

> Valve intentionally withdrawing themselves from the ecosystem is purely out of spite

“Boohoo stupid Gabe does that out of pure naughtiness.”

I hope you realize how childish your statement is.