News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop EU Chat Control by makeitdouble on Monday October 09, 2023 @11:14PM (#37828147)
They'd have less success and support if the EU wasn't the only entity doing something about antitrust and market abuse. This kind of massive initiative becomes realistic because they've been battling for ages against the tech giants and know they can take the heat.
Re:Stop EU Chat Control by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @12:30AM (#37828520)
Are they though? They make a lot of noise about it but meanwhile who have they broken up? You can't even replace the OS your phone came with in most cases, Safari/Chrome derivatives are 95% of the browser market, app stores are still charging 30% with no meaningful competition and excluding apps that compete with their own, Qualcomm et al don't publish what's necessary to produce indepedent firmware for the zillion devices that use their chips and whose OEMs went out of business or otherwise stopped updating them.

Sound and fury is nothing. Actually fix some of these.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @01:31AM (#37828819)
Please tell me where this fairy tale comes from that either Apple or Google are excluding apps that compete with its own?
Re:Stop EU Chat Control by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @02:34AM (#37829136)
Apple, for iOS? You have to use their browser engine, you can't install anything like a JVM or the .NET runtime that competes with their APIs, you can't replace the Apple libraries that other apps use even if you were willing to implement the same interface, you have to use their App Store app to install other apps, you can't produce kernel drivers for third party hardware, pretty much all of the software they include with the device you're proscribed from replacing with a competing offering from someone else.
Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @08:14AM (#37831084)
All that and you still haven’t shown where “you can’t install an app that competes with their own”

Microsoft and Google both have cross platform frameworks for iOS and Android.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @11:45AM (#37833622)
Browsers with their own browser engines and bytecode runtimes are apps. These are the exact things Microsoft got in trouble for in the 90s -- because they enable competition.

A translation layer between a generic API and Apple's isn't the same thing. It can't add things Apple's doesn't already have. For example, how do you run CUDA or OpenCL code on Apple's devices? Can a cross-platform framework provide a payments implementation so your cross-platform app can use a cross-platform payments system for in-app purchases? No, because they make you use theirs and apps that compete with theirs aren't allowed.

Visual Studio Code is clearly an app. Apple doesn't allow it on iOS. Apple makes a competing app -- for which they want you to buy a Mac.

You can't just use a definition of "app" that means "whatever is in their app store" and then claim that whatever they don't allow in their app store isn't an app.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @12:25PM (#37834208)
A bytceode runtime is not an “application”.

Apple never stopped VSCode from being on iOS. There are plenty of IDEs for the iPad built by third parties.

No one would ever call a virtual machine an “application”.

Are you making up things now? You don’t run CUDA on any non Nvidia hardware.

But yes, you are free to port OpenCL to iOS if you want to.

> Can a cross-platform framework provide a payments implementation so your cross-platform app can use a cross-platform payments system for in-app purchases

A “payment API” is not an “application”. Yes the cross platform frameworks do expose the underlying API.

And you can have a cross platform app that forces you to subscribe outside of the App Store - Spotify, Netflix, Microsoft, etc all do that.

> No because they make you use theirs and apps that compete with theirs aren't allowed.

Are you saying that their no competitors on iOS to AppleTV, Apple Music, Apple Podcasts, Apple Books, the iWork suite?

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by smoldesu on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @01:18PM (#37834796)
> You don’t run CUDA on any non Nvidia hardware.

CUDA drivers exist for pretty much every platform. They don't work without an Nvidia GPU, but in-theory nothing stops you from running CUDA code on iPhone besides Apple.

> Are you saying that their no competitors on iOS

None with the same competitive advantage as Apple. Whether that is fair or not seems to be up to individual markets.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @01:53PM (#37835227)
So exactly how is Apple stopping you from implementing the entire CUDA API as a library to include within your application noting that no one has done it on non Nvidia hardware?

So are you saying that

- Apple Music is more popular on iOS than Spotify?

- The iWork’s suite is more popular than MSOffice or GSuite?

- AppleTV is more popular than Netflix?

- Apple Books is more popular than Kindle?

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by smoldesu on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @04:58PM (#37837361)
> So exactly how is Apple stopping you from implementing the entire CUDA API

Well, neither the hardware or software supports PCI access, so... connectivity would be a start. It's about time iPhone supported Thunderbolt anyways.

> So are you saying that {Apple Music is more popular on iOS than Spotify?, ...}

I'm saying that Apple exerts a literal anticompetitive advantage by choosing their own margins (among many other things). Nothing about legislation like the Digital Market Act accuses Apple of monopoly. It designates them as a Gatekeeper (a position Apple chose) and holds them subject to additional guidelines. That is the cost of owning a userbase in Europe, now.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @05:36PM (#37837911)
Yes it should support thunderbolt like all of the Android manufacturers.

How is Apple “choosing their own margins?” None of the example I listed pay Apple one penny for in app purchases.

I guess since the tech industry in Europe can’t export anything worthwhile, passing legislation is the best they have.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by smoldesu on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @08:02PM (#37839360)
> I guess since the tech industry in Europe can’t export anything worthwhile

Let's see!

I, for one, would be very excited to watch Apple admit that the European audience isn't worth their while. After all, Apple acquires their companies year[0] after year[1] after year[2] after year[3] after year[4] after year[5] after year[6] after year[7] after year[8] after year[9] after year[10] after year[11] after year[12] after year[13].

Well, maybe Europe matters to Apple... b-but not much!

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BIS_Records

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/ronshevlin/2022/03/27/why-apple...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primephonic

[3] https://www.macrumors.com/2020/04/03/apple-acquires-ai-start...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_XMM_modems

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialog_Semiconductor

[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beddit

[7] https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-acquired-finnish-compa...

[8] https://techcrunch.com/2015/11/24/apple-faceshift/

[9] https://www.pcmag.com/news/report-apple-buys-digital-magazin...

[10] https://techcrunch.com/2013/08/28/apple-reportedly-acquires-...

[11] https://www.macrumors.com/2012/05/30/apple-acquiring-italian...

[12] https://venturebeat.com/mobile/apple-buys-c3-technologies-on...

[13] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polar_Rose_(facial_recognition...

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @08:58PM (#37839735)
So none of them could make it on their own as an ongoing concern…
Re:Stop EU Chat Control by smoldesu on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @12:06PM (#37846283)
Evidently Apple can't make it on their own, either. If Europe meant nothing to them, they'd just leave.

...I don't even give a half-shit about Europe, either. I just find it funny how their sovereignty pisses off corporate sycophants so much. People like you actually get worked-up into writing comment-after-comment of non-argument, refusing to write something more substantiated than ad-hominem attacks. All I have to do to refute you is cite my sources.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @01:16PM (#37847306)
This coming from someone who is asking why you can’t use CUDA - which only works on Nvidia hardware on ab iPhone and then suggest Apple supports external GPUs via Thunderbolt on the iPhone just in case someone wants to carry around an Nvidua breakout box to do intensive GPU work on an iPhone.

Of course you would also need a power plug.

And this is why when you leave geeks to their own devices they end up designing something like the Homermobile.

And none of “Apple’s competitors” pay a penny for in app purchases to Apple. They all force you to subscribe outside of the App Store.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by smoldesu on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @03:11PM (#37848930)
Now you're back down to ad-hominem again.

> you can’t use CUDA - which only works on Nvidia hardware

Tell me you've never used CUDA without telling me you've never used CUDA.

Before Apple revoked Nvidia's certificates, they in fact did support CUDA on Apple hardware. You needed an Nvidia GPU to run it, but Apple hardware and software is a perfectly usable client: https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/drivers/cuda/mac-driver-archive...

Failing that, Nvidia still maintains BSD-style drivers if Apple did let them install their drivers. Now you're going to yell at me about how this is an unrealistic workflow, but plugging your iPhone or Mac into a TV, DAC or external drive isn't.

> just in case someone wants to carry around an Nvidua breakout box to do intensive GPU work on an iPhone.

Sure. They exist, nothing on the technical side stops Apple from implementing it. My point is not that they must add the feature, but that it is totally possible if Apple didn't arbitrarily limit userspace drivers. Draw your own conclusions about it, I couldn't give less of a shit.

If changing the iPhone to Thunderbolt and supporting eGPUs in software is equivalent to a "Homermobile" in your head, get a grip.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @03:27PM (#37849145)
> Before Apple revoked Nvidia's certificates, they in fact did support CUDA on Apple hardware. You needed an Nvidia GPU to run it, but Apple hardware and software is a perfectly usable client:

> Now you're going to yell at me about how this is an unrealistic workflow, but plugging your iPhone or Mac into a TV, DAC or external drive isn't.

So how large do you think the market is for an external GPU on a phone? If there were a market for it, why isn’t anyone doing it on an Android phone?

We are talking about iPhones - not Macs. If you can engineer an Nvidia breakout box for ARM based Macs, there is nothing stopping you from turning off System Integrity Protection and installing an unsigned driver and you doing it yourself.

> Failing that, Nvidia still maintains BSD-style drivers if Apple did let them install their drivers.

You can turn off SIP right now and do it, good luck getting that working on an ARM based Mac where even Apple hasn’t architected a method yet to use third party GPUs.

> Sure. They exist, nothing on the technical side stops Apple from implementing it. My point is not that they must add the feature, but that it is totally possible if Apple didn't arbitrarily limit userspace drivers. Draw your own conclusions about it, I couldn't give less of a shit.

If there were a market for it on phones why doesn’t it exist for Android?

> If changing the iPhone to Thunderbolt and supporting eGPUs in software is equivalent to a "Homermobile" in your head, get a grip.

Yet no Android supports an external breakout box for eGPUs. Maybe it is a Homermobile?

The iPad Pros do in fact support Thunderbolt.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by smoldesu on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @04:26PM (#37849829)
Like I said in the last 2 comments, I honestly don't care about this. The fact that you reached for my CUDA meme as a legitimate counterpoint after being refuted so hard is almost heartbreaking. You can rest, you don't have to spend every opportunity grinding your axe on a corporation's behalf.

It is really funny watching you be butthurt about European regulators though. Can we go back to that, or will I have to wait for the bill to hit frontpage again? If you're done complaining about that stuff, I don't think we have much more to talk about (sorry for cutting out the eGPU detour, hope you had fun).

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @05:29PM (#37850494)
Have I been refuted?

You could if you had the technical prowess create an Nvidia breakout box for the Mac right now Apple doesn’t stop you from doing anything you want. You brought up Apple stopping you from running CUDA on Apple hardware

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by smoldesu on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @07:05PM (#37851523)
> Have I been refuted?

Hopefully you realize the original Europe claims were absurd. But uhh... up to you pal. Clearly we live worlds apart.

> You could if you had the technical prowess create an Nvidia breakout box for the Mac right now

You can't even do it on Linux without official Nvidia drivers, which Apple refuses to sign for MacOS. Nouveau is veritably broken on modern GPU hardware; you either run the blob or get 2D raster output at 20FPS and no power management.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @09:26PM (#37852430)
What does Apple not signing drivers for MacOS have to do with it not running on Linux?

And what part of you can disable system integrity protection on MacOS and run unsigned drivers is hard to comprehend?

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @03:04PM (#37836098)
> A bytceode runtime is not an “application”.

It's not hardware.

Would you be happier if I said "excluding software that competes with their own"?

Why would it be any better if they are excluding hardware that competes with their own?

> Apple never stopped VSCode from being on iOS. There are plenty of IDEs for the iPad built by third parties.

VSCode is an app that needs the .NET runtime, in order to run the code you write in e.g. C#. They don't allow the runtime it needs which means they don't allow the app (which competes with theirs).

> Are you making up things now? You don’t run CUDA on any non Nvidia hardware.

iPads have Thunderbolt, so you could actually plug NVIDIA hardware into them. Or someone could port CUDA to Apple's GPUs, as AMD essentially did with HIP. Except that would be this:

> But yes, you are free to port OpenCL to iOS if you want to.

Implementing such a thing efficiently requires driver support, but you can't modify the drivers nor supply your own.

> A “payment API” is not an “application”. Yes the cross platform frameworks do expose the underlying API.

A payments system is a part of an application. They prohibit broad categories of apps that use any but their own payments system.

Using Apple's payments API doesn't allow for apps that use a competing payments system, which was the whole point.

> And you can have a cross platform app that forces you to subscribe outside of the App Store - Spotify, Netflix, Microsoft, etc all do that.

I point to a category of thing they prohibit and then you point to the exception that proves the rule as if that meant they don't impose the rule.

We know they don't do it for a specific subset of subscription services anymore. They still do it in general, which is to say that they still do it.

> Are you saying that their no competitors on iOS to AppleTV, Apple Music, Apple Podcasts, Apple Books, the iWork suite?

This is the same thing again. It's not a question of if they prohibit every app that competes with theirs, it's a question of if they prohibit any app that competes with theirs.

Which they do. You can't get real Firefox on iOS:

https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/add-ons-firefox-ios

And it's not because Mozilla doesn't want to provide it.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @03:46PM (#37836567)
> It's not hardware.

So now are kernel extensions also “applications”?

> VSCode is an app that needs the .NET runtime, in order to run the code you write in e.g. C#.

You could not possibly be more wrong. VSCode is written in Typescript. It is an Electron app. There have been cross platform JS frameworks that ran on iOS for a decade.

Besides that, it’s been years since you have needed the .Net runtime to run .Net applications.

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/uwp/dotnet-native/

And Microsoft already has a solution to run .Net code on iOS

https://dotnet.microsoft.com/en-us/apps/mobile

> payments system is a part of an application. They prohibit broad categories of apps that use any but their own payments system.

There is an existence proof that there are applications that exist on iOS right now that force you to pay outside of their ecosystem.

Are you really crying over pay to win games?

> We know they don't do it for a specific subset of subscription services anymore. They still do it in general, which is to say that they still do it

Can you name any none pay to win games that couldn’t be a subscription service outside of the App Store?

And your solution to supporting CUDA is a breakout box on an iPad with an nvidua card? Who the hell is going to buy that?

There is nothing stopping

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by AnthonyMouse on Thursday October 12, 2023 @05:25PM (#37863359)
> So now are kernel extensions also “applications”?

They're things some "applications" need in order to function, so if you can't include them you've effectively prohibited those applications.

But what does it matter if something is an "application" or not? Why is it any better if Apple precludes third parties from competing with their kernel extensions?

> VSCode is written in Typescript. It is an Electron app.

It's not the IDE you have to be able to run, it's the code you write in it.

> And Microsoft already has a solution to run .Net code on iOS

That's just compiling the code to a native binary, which you would then have to go submit through Apple's store. How does that help for an IDE expected to allow you to test (i.e. execute) and debug the code you've just written ten seconds ago?

> Can you name any none pay to win games that couldn’t be a subscription service outside of the App Store?

https://developer.apple.com/support/reader-apps/

We can see right there some examples of what isn't allowed:

Not facilitate real-time, person-to-person services (e.g., providing tutoring services, medical consultations, real estate tours, or fitness training).

Apps that let people access digital content such as music or video, but not as the primary functionality, are not considered reader apps and are not eligible for the External Link Account Entitlement. For example, a social networking app that lets people stream audiovisual content is not eligible.

> And your solution to supporting CUDA is a breakout box on an iPad with an nvidua card? Who the hell is going to buy that?

Presumably the same sort of people who buy the existing graphics card docks on the market for other platforms.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by scarface_74 on Sunday October 15, 2023 @01:20AM (#37887092)
There are plenty of solutions for running Python in an IDE on the iPad. There is an even an x86 emulator and a Linux terminal built on top of it in the App Store.

https://ish.app/

It can run anything that you can run on an x86 in user mode. I downloaded the AWS CLI (which requires Python) to run some tests

By the way, you were completely wrong about VSCode being written in .Net.

> That's just compiling the code to a native binary, which you would then have to go submit through Apple's store. How does that help for an IDE expected to allow you to test (i.e. execute) and debug the code you've just written ten seconds ago?

There is an existence proof that it could be done. If you ran iSH with remote VNC you could have a full IDE on a Mac.

> We can see right there some examples of what isn't allowed: Not facilitate real-time, person-to-person services (e.g., providing tutoring services, medical consultations, real estate tours, or fitness training).

You lack imagination. I actually know someone who does fitness classes online where most people use iPads and doesn’t pay Apple a dime - she’s sleeping right next to me. She uses Zoom.

> But what does it matter if something is an "application" or not? Why is it any better if Apple precludes third parties from competing with their kernel extensions?

It matters because once you allow kernel extensions it can bypass the security sandbox.

Do you also think that Apple should allow third parties access to the Secure Enclave?

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by makeitdouble on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @08:13AM (#37831081)
You're asking these questions as if others have shown strides in all these domains and they're table stakes.

Apple got asked why they take 30% by the US gov, answered that they just like money, and never got asked anything again. The only gov that could do squat on that front is China. Netherlands and Korea barely got some small exceptions.

Same way Google's only trial that went anywhere regarding Google Services binding happened in EU, and the only country that got away with a vibrant android ecosystem is China (to my knowledge...does India do too?)

I'll poopoo Eu's efforts when another entity actually splits Google away, and I'll be really happy to do so, trust me.

Re:Stop EU Chat Control by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @11:09AM (#37833065)
You're using "at least they do something about antitrust" as an excuse for all their poorly thought out rules that increase compliance burdens and actually make competing in those markets harder. You can't then say "well the US isn't doing it" -- the US isn't imposing higher compliance costs either.