There's a difference between cooperating with the government - my country, Germany, is infamous for the close webs between government and its car companies - but there is no chain of command (other than a partial stake that Lower Saxony holds in VW) between the industry and politics. If anything, it's the other way around, companies pay a shitload in "party donations" to have the government represent its interest in the EU and abroad.
> And this argument is so tired that it even has its own Wikipedia page explaining that it is a logical fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children
A lot of TOTC is bullshit and usually pulled for the ulterior motive of (effectively) banning stuff for adults by imposing obscene obstacles (such as the planned EU chat control, or British anti-porn legislation). But here, it's aimed squarely at adolescents who use Tiktok as their most popular news source [1] - no matter what, that IS dangerous.
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/jul/20/tiktok-is...
See the disappearance of Naomi Wu or Peng Shuai.
Why would you want people learning that censorship or misinformation from an authoritarian foreign power is good? Should the goal be to create a repressive dictatorship here?
In any case, comparing the level of control of "major commercial actors often work in conjecture with their government" sounds awfully stretched.
This was used during my childhood by the Reagan (and subsequent) administration as justification for cracking down on the drug war and leading us closer to a police state, skirting constitutional rights, etc. Of course the children they were supposedly protecting got arrested for smoking pot and underage drinking and whatnot, damaging their lives and future outlook, sometimes significantly.
That doesn't mean that threats to the well-being of children don't actually exist. Your blanket rejection is no better than the insincere use of TOTC.
Statements like that really make me question people's knowledge of basic history and international politics. Yes, a nation's major commercial actors often work in conjecture with their government. Is this news to anyone? This is not unique to China in the least.
> The second difference/risk comes with looking whom these apps target: kids.
And this argument is so tired that it even has its own Wikipedia page explaining that it is a logical fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children