News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by perihelions on Monday October 09, 2023 @06:09AM (#37818783)
- "and what can EU do about it? Nothing"

The answer's right in front of you: the EU's imposing tariffs on goods exported from China into the EU. China is an export economy. This matters to them.

(I mean, if you want to argue that China is turning inward and its internal market will soon be the largest consumption market on the planet, sidelining the EU, I'll concede that. But in the near term, the EU market is a globally super-influential one. These policies are not irrelevant).

Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by inglor_cz on Monday October 09, 2023 @07:44AM (#37819361)
This only works up to a point.

First, European voters may well decide that they don't care about carbon emissions that much; with every economic downturn, the green parties tend to lose votes and the far right gains.

Second, "reeducation by tariffs" will produce resentments that may bite us back. I can see the reverse happening later; e.g. India adding extra tariffs to its own products unless we accept Hindutva.

Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by JumpCrisscross on Monday October 09, 2023 @07:55AM (#37819461)
> European voters may well decide that they don't care about carbon emissions that much

This is tautology--of course it won't work if people don't want to do it anymore.

> India adding extra tariffs to its own products unless we accept Hindutva

If someone is stupid enough to do this, they don't need a reason.

Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by inglor_cz on Monday October 09, 2023 @08:40AM (#37819826)
"If someone is stupid enough to do this, they don't need a reason."

Politicians love to play tit for tat, because that gives them a plausible excuse for the masses. And you may underestimate the weight that ideologically based states put on their official ideology.

IDK if it will be Hindutva and India, but we will likely see some Chinese attempts to enforce their own sensitivites. They already try to do so at universities which have a lot of Chinese students.

Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by throwbadubadu on Monday October 09, 2023 @10:55AM (#37821097)
Reeducation? I don't understand this.

If I have whatever believed higher standards to something (be it carbon-free, worker protection, no child work, or whatever) but other's on the global market do not, and it makes things massively cheaper, I can only have tariffs or drop my standards (or not care about competitiveness of my industries). What other alternatives exist?

Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by rad_gruchalski on Monday October 09, 2023 @08:59AM (#37820015)
> The answer's right in front of you: the EU's imposing tariffs on goods exported from China into the EU. China is an export economy. This matters to them.

Not until there's a cheaper alternative. Until then they will not care, the life will be just more expensive for everyone in the EU.

Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by dublinben on Monday October 09, 2023 @09:34AM (#37820312)
EU states can use some or all of this revenue for a direct dividend to citizens, like in Canada. That would make most people better off than before, in direct financial terms.
Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by Detrytus on Monday October 09, 2023 @11:01AM (#37821165)
So they will be taking money from citizens in form of taxes so they can give it back to those same citizens? Seems like a lot of time-wasting bureaucracy.
Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by itishappy on Monday October 09, 2023 @11:25AM (#37821407)
Yes, money will be given back that was previously leaving the country.
Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by Detrytus on Monday October 09, 2023 @02:26PM (#37823520)
No, this money wasn't leaving the country.

Suppose some item from China costs $100. Now EU will add, say, $15 tax to it, for the total price of $115. So, $100 is going to China, as previously, and $15 tax paid by EU citizens is redistributed among EU citizens. And no, do not expect Chinese companies to just eat the tax, because their profit margins are usually already thin, as they are competing on price in many markets.

This may change, eventually, if Europe finally learns to manufacture things themselves, but that's a long and hard way. For at least the next decade they will have no choice but eat the tax and continue buying from China.

Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by wkat4242 on Monday October 09, 2023 @03:45PM (#37824561)
And that €15 will not go directly back to the citizens but more likely to corrupt banks or other enterprises.
Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by wedernoch on Monday October 09, 2023 @04:49PM (#37825323)
Before:

* EU product 115€

* China product 100€

After:

* EU product 115€

* China product 115€

So chinese product can't just outcompete on price. And the money may actually sty in the EU.

Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by itishappy on Monday October 09, 2023 @06:43PM (#37826376)
That's $100 leaving the country.

> And no, do not expect Chinese companies to just eat the tax, because their profit margins are usually already thin, as they are competing on price in many markets.

That's the point. From the article:

> Under the new regime, an importer of Chinese steel will have to purchase carbon credits that correspond to the same rate as steel produced in the European Union.

Europe already produces this stuff, they're just being outcompeted by China subsidizing their costs using the environment. Since China and Europe happen to be share big parts of the environment, Europe feels environmental effects no matter where the steal is produced.

Yes, I am suggesting they were already paying for this (just not with money). I think the EU is too.

Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by benj111 on Monday October 09, 2023 @09:50AM (#37820433)
That's the point. It makes the green alternatives relatively cheaper.

Or if not. The tax helps pay for the negative externalities.

Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by Detrytus on Monday October 09, 2023 @11:08AM (#37821237)
Or the “green alternatives” will become more expensive, because why the hell not? If your competitors just raised prices it makes it easier for you to do the same, without consequences.
Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by itishappy on Monday October 09, 2023 @11:21AM (#37821363)
They may, or they may choose higher volumes for the same price. There are always consequences.
Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by rad_gruchalski on Monday October 09, 2023 @11:21AM (#37821371)
Sure, right. Like heat pumps in Germany. Every time there's Forderung available, prices skyrocket.
Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by wedernoch on Monday October 09, 2023 @04:47PM (#37825295)
It's Förderung, not Forderung. Two totally different words.

Forderung: demand, requirement Förderung: financial support (what you mean)

I guess the price spikes happen because demand spikes in these situations..

Re:The EU Just Kicked Off Its Biggest Climate Experiment Yet by rad_gruchalski on Monday October 09, 2023 @06:23PM (#37826197)
> It's Förderung, not Forderung. Two totally different words.

You have umlauts on your keyboard, yay! Vielen Dank und viele Grüße.

> I guess the price spikes happen because demand spikes in these situations..

Seems like a lot of people, and the government, guess like you. Everyone's kinda bummed in Germany that Förderung becomes available, resellers jack prices up, Förderung ends up in the pocket of the reseller. Typical money grab. Viel Öko.

As the gov is already regulating the market, they can opt to regulate the price cap for something they fund anyway. No? Same with solar panels.

I mean, it's not like the government has their own money. People of Germany fund Förderung. So people fund it in taxes so they can get in Förderung so that a group of people gets rich on the wave of the Förderung. It would be okay if people weren't forced into this technology.

Oh, what would one give to be on the drawing board of the Klimawandel and have the first hand knowledge of what people are going to be strong-armed into. Sounds like a perfect condition to put oneself in a position to greatly benefit out of it.