Dressing up to an appropriate level shows you care.
The thing about the good investors the OP is talking about is that, increasingly, they don't do this. There are two reasons why they don't. One (which applies to only some, like YC) is that they are technical people themselves. The other is that the ones who do it lose to the ones who don't.
That is the historical trend and it has little to with fads or fashions. It has to do with economic power shifting towards people who create things.
1. http://www.blogcdn.com/www.tuaw.com/media/2011/04/woz-return...
2. http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lpmlgqzYtY1qafiav.jpg
3. http://www.pcbdesign007.com/articlefiles/77213-max%20woz.jpg
4. http://cdn02.cdnwp.celebuzz.com/wp-content/uploads/legacy-im...
Highly relevant snippet taken from the quote you responded to. Please look it up if you are not familiar with the phrase.
Conformity isn't evil per se, but judging people for lack of it often is.
Interestingly, "conformity" is one of those words that no one uses about themselves. Like "tourist".
I also don't think tailored executive suits are what is being discussed.
I'll also add that as a member of a certain minority community, I've been criticized by peers for not sporting an "authentic" style, despite the fact that 98% of potential employers would likely send me packing were I to show up to an interview in said style. You don't know how someone will interpret your appearance, so unless you really know your audience, the smart money says "look good for investors" (or employers etc)