I do think there are some specific details about Patreon's history and leadership that make it unusually bad at running an engineering organization, even for a VC-backed startup. It has some deceptively hard engineering problems and has struggled to attract, retain, and use technical leadership equal to those problems.
And he largely succeeded at that goal! He made the word “patron” into household vernacular, at a time when most people knew it as a historical term for something only royalty would do. And uncountable artists were helped.
I think it’s clear to us in 2023 that it’s been harder than expected for a lot of venture-backed businesses to become sustainable overnight. But that doesn’t make the model evil or feudalist by necessity - if the Patreon example tells us anything, it is that the venture model can bring great good to the world.
Neophilia is a progressive and incurable disease of venture capital. VCs aren't looking to build sustainable, profitable businesses. They are looking to buy entire market segments for later enshittification. Your job as a founder of a company asking for VC money is to construct a parallel state around your target market so that you can charge taxes on everyone in that market and that the VCs can sell the entire market to someone else for a huge profit (the "exit").
Jack Conte is very firmly an artist, and not a walking pile of technofeudalist money, so I can't help but look at this as a deal-with-the-devil scenario. Or at the very least, someone desperately trying and failing to keep the money on track. The VCs bought a payment bundler and want to turn it into a merch vendor, website host, etc.