News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Charlie Stross on Girls Around Me by tptacek on Saturday March 31, 2012 @12:16PM (#3780641)
This notion that Facebook artificially suppresses the multiple "roles" (parent, teacher, officemate, spouse) people live in their real lives is a red herring. Stross tries to make a point by suggesting teachers don't want students to see into their private lives. Yes. And this is why teachers don't friend students on Facebook.

In reality, Facebook doesn't suppress those roles; it just doesn't support them (and when it comes close, perhaps accidentally, that's when Fb can start to get a little awkward --- like, my Dad is an Fb friend; but: some people have adult friendships with their parents! [My dad is still my dad]).

But most people do have a somewhat coherent role of "adult out in the real world interacting with peers, friends, and acquaintances in a social setting". It's the role you play when you go to a coworker's house party, or to a bar, or to the park. This is a huge part of most people's lives. Capturing it in social software is not a minor achievement.

The expectation that Facebook should do so much more than that, dividing people's lives perfectly into facets like "immediate family" and "work group", seems off. It may not even be possible. Just don't friend those people.

Re:Charlie Stross on Girls Around Me by zeroonetwothree on Sunday April 01, 2012 @04:36AM (#3783118)
Exactly. For some people it makes sense to be Facebook friends with their parents, because they interact with them socially.

It probably never makes sense to be Facebook friends with your students, but then why would you want a relationship with them at all on any social network? It just doesn't seem like an appropriate forum for that relationship. It's not as if Facebook is meant to replace all communication online.