News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by TheAlchemist on Saturday October 07, 2023 @04:41PM (#37805360)
Well, this guy didn't become a legend by accident, that's for sure !

Reading this log, I can't stop thinking how clear things needed to be in his head to advance at that pace. Like he already had everything programmed in his mind, he was just transcribing it for the computer.

Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by beebeepka on Saturday October 07, 2023 @05:23PM (#37805693)
Isn't that what programming is like? I guess the main challenge is to avoid lying to yourself by downplaying stuff that is problematic.
Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by Jiocus on Saturday October 07, 2023 @07:50PM (#37806571)
The hard part is knowing what parts -and why- you need to load into your head, so work can even begin.
Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by userbinator on Saturday October 07, 2023 @11:47PM (#37807717)
Some are like this, and others tend to have more of a "mess around and try things until it works" style. In fact I've noticed a lot more programmers in the latter category than the former.
Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by asalahli on Sunday October 08, 2023 @12:35AM (#37807900)
Edsger Dijkstra calls it Mozart vs Beethoven style of programming in an interview.

https://youtu.be/-Uae9_pgZzE

Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by tjpnz on Sunday October 08, 2023 @04:34AM (#37808824)
Can the former even exist today?
Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by abraae on Saturday October 07, 2023 @08:11PM (#37806695)
I looked at one of the work logs. Thought "that's a fair amount to get done in a week". Then realised it was just one day. Man is a machine!
Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by FirmwareBurner on Saturday October 07, 2023 @10:43PM (#37807448)
He said he works 13h days.
Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by voytec on Sunday October 08, 2023 @01:51AM (#37808168)
Final log excerpt:

> Vacation? I don't need a vacation!

Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by markus_zhang on Sunday October 08, 2023 @08:05AM (#37809745)
Or maybe: I'm having vacations every day!
Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by anonymoose33282 on Monday October 09, 2023 @10:00AM (#37820535)
Sometimes I wish I could go back to the 90s (or even early/mid 2000s) just for a day to remember what that vacuum of "stuff to do" in every day life was like.

I lived it, I remember "being bored" or having "nothing to do", but I truly can't access it in a meaningful way. I would love to go back to those days of playing games or engaging in my hobbies where I didn't feel that constant pressure of "but you better get stuff done, we don't have all day here".

Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by loa_in_ on Saturday October 07, 2023 @08:18PM (#37806741)
I can't help but notice that the days are continuous, with not many (two day) gaps in between.
Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by FirmwareBurner on Saturday October 07, 2023 @11:04PM (#37807549)
It was a start-up where he was a founder and major shareholder, and Quake was his own pet project, so of course he worked nearly 7 days/week.
Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by shortrounddev2 on Sunday October 08, 2023 @11:05AM (#37811124)
> Not only was the future of the company at stake but he also enjoyed doing it.

The business concerns were not a major factor for Carmack. He was against expanding the business and the company was making plenty of money with a lot of cash to spare. They had other projects other than Quake that were making them money. Had he really cared about the health of the business, he wouldn't have lashed out so much at other developers working on things other than Quake. He simply thought the company should basically work on one project at a time.

Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by chandler5555 on Saturday October 07, 2023 @11:29PM (#37807652)
found more of his logs by googling and my favorite is that he worked on xmas and new years eve in 1997. impressive focus
Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by marginalia_nu on Sunday October 08, 2023 @07:40AM (#37809633)
I used to have a somewhat similar system, basically just a stack/heap system where I'd push/pop one list into another list of dated completed items, and I think I fairly often ended up with a huge volume of points.

It's a bit self-reinforcing, the practice of jotting down unrelated threads you come up with makes them easy to pick up later, so you always have stack of problems to attack without having any of them cluttering your head as you execute.

Often when I'm not doing stuff, it's because I don't have a clear picture of what I should do next, or how to do the next thing. This is not a problem I had working like this. It was all execution.

Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by onetimeuse92304 on Sunday October 08, 2023 @08:23AM (#37809853)
I understand this will not explain entirety of it, but when you concentrate responsibility, decision making and ability to do all things through entirety of the application, you can move much, much faster than what all of us are used to working for regular companies.

It almost feels, and sometimes is cheating.

I was confronted with this when I felt really fantastic being super productive at one of the projects and then a team member pointed out that I am also tech lead, architect and a manager all in one and I simply don't work by the same rules as everybody else. Where everybody else has to get permissions, approvals, concensus, inputs, has to wait for other people to do things, I can just do it all in my head and act immediately. This taught me an important lesson and I am now much more conscious of this fact and spending way more time trying to remove any barriers from other team members.

This also explains why solo developers can sometimes achieve so much -- they simply don't have to work with anybody else. They don't have to understand code somebody else designed and wrote. They don't have to spend time arguing defending their approach or solutions. They know how everything works and can make all decisions solely on whether it helps them to achieve the result. Synchronising with other people is a huge overhead in any organisation.

Re:John Carmack's Quake Worklogs by shortrounddev2 on Sunday October 08, 2023 @11:02AM (#37811097)
That's sort of the myth behind the guy, but from Romero's account in Doom Guy, Carmack was pushing himself to the limit. He didn't sleep, he didn't take breaks, and he frequently rewrote things that other engineers wrote from scratch. While his code was great, his faculties as an employee and manager greatly suffered. He started lashing out at other developers and became an utter tyrant of a boss when he began to perceive that the lack of similar effort on behalf of other developers was unfair. I think he really struggled with Quake 1, especially since he had to teach himself all the math required, having no background in math