Re:John Carmack and Rich Sutton partner to accelerate develo...
by TedDoesntTalk on Saturday October 07, 2023 @04:09PM
(#37805099)
> namely the belief that you can know what the results of your actions will be with any meaningful completeness or certitude. You can't.
In parallel threads, a subscriber to this belief mentions probabilities. As long as the probability of an outcome is likely (based on variables and formulas who defines, I don’t know), the means justify the ends. So it’s even worse than what you describe: certitude is not even required, only a likely probability of certitude.
Under most utilitarian theories of ethics, I think it's morally required, if you can show the fraud really does yield a significantly higher QALY count.
The best out I can see to argue the fraud is not required is to show that another course of action will yield even more QALYs. Then you'd be obligated you do that instead.
That, of course, comes to another fundamental flaws of utilitarianism, namely the belief that you can know what the results of your actions will be with any meaningful completeness or certitude.
You can't.
Without that it's all just excuses that justify whatever you want to do.