Re:Signs of undeclared ChatGPT use in papers mounting
by breakwaterlabs on Tuesday October 10, 2023 @11:46AM
(#37833643)
If the system is not catching "I am a language model", I have zero confidence in its ability to detect crackpottery, much less more insidious things like P-hacking.
Depends on how much the journal is willing to push the authors (predatory journals don't give a heck, prestigious journals usually care more because they've got a rep to uphold). Reviewers can be anyone from an expert in the field, a competitor who gives you a hard time (usually they're not actively malicious though), to some random prof doing it because the editor couldn't find anyone else, or even a grad student in the lab of a prof (it's a common training exercise).
I've had articles with anywhere from 1-3 reviewers, there is no standard beyond "the editor is a basic crackpottery filter, there is an external reviewer, and a copy editor makes it fit for viewing"