News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jailed Iranian Activist Narges Mohammadi Wins 2023 Nobel ... by imjonse on Friday October 06, 2023 @08:18AM (#37789738)
To be fair, Mandela did not get it while imprisoned and while the US and the UK were tacit supporters of the Apartheid regime.

And Maria Ressa seems anti-Duterte, and pro-US if I read correctly.

Re:Jailed Iranian Activist Narges Mohammadi Wins 2023 Nobel ... by LindeBuzoGray on Friday October 06, 2023 @08:34AM (#37789911)
Right, Mandela got it when he was being conciliatory to the government and its Western support, with other ANC elements being less so.

The same with Arafat - he was conciliatory to Israel and its western support at Oslo, with Hamas and the PFLP being less so.

Both were not fighting when.they got the prize, but being conciliatory.

Re:Jailed Iranian Activist Narges Mohammadi Wins 2023 Nobel ... by fauigerzigerk on Friday October 06, 2023 @08:41AM (#37789983)
I don't agree that Arafat was fighting any less than Narges Mohammadi when he got the Nobel Peace Prize. He didn't get the prize for surrendering.
Re:Jailed Iranian Activist Narges Mohammadi Wins 2023 Nobel ... by fauigerzigerk on Friday October 06, 2023 @08:38AM (#37789956)
>Mandela did not get it while imprisoned and while the US and the UK were tacit supporters of the Apartheid regime

True

>Maria Ressa seems anti-Duterte, and pro-US if I read correctly

Duterte is/was a Trump style figure in a country that houses U.S military bases. If Pakistan counts then the Philippines must count as well.

Re:Jailed Iranian Activist Narges Mohammadi Wins 2023 Nobel ... by imjonse on Friday October 06, 2023 @09:10AM (#37790305)
I mean the Philippines is traditionally a US ally, but Duterte both openly criticised the US and tried to get closer to China. And Maria Ressa is definitely not an anti-US or anti-Western activist.
Re:Jailed Iranian Activist Narges Mohammadi Wins 2023 Nobel ... by fauigerzigerk on Friday October 06, 2023 @09:54AM (#37790839)
>but Duterte both openly criticised the US and tried to get closer to China

Yes he did for a moment before completely reversing course.

https://www.rand.org/blog/2021/11/dutertes-dalliance-with-ch...

Pakistan's various leaders on the other hand have criticised the U.S far more harshly and far more persistently over the years. They have also had close relations with China for decades.

Re:Jailed Iranian Activist Narges Mohammadi Wins 2023 Nobel ... by imjonse on Friday October 06, 2023 @11:49AM (#37792366)
There are no peace Nobel prizes for such Pakistanis though. Malala got it for figthing for education of young girls. Although I no longer remember how Pakistan got into the discussion and if we're arguing or agreeing :)
Re:Jailed Iranian Activist Narges Mohammadi Wins 2023 Nobel ... by dragonwriter on Friday October 06, 2023 @11:12AM (#37791851)
> To be fair, Mandela did not get it while imprisoned and while the US and the UK were tacit supporters of the Apartheid regime.

To be even more fair, Mandela wasn’t the first anti-apartheid Nobel Peace Prize award, and Albert John Lutuli (awarded 1960) and Archbishop Tutu (awarded 1984) got it for fighting apartheid when the US and UK were tacit (active, of the regime if not the apartheid policy specifically, in 1960) supporters of the apartheid regime (Reagan’s reversal on his “constructive engagement” approach came inmediately after Archbishop Tutu's address to Congress and subsequent meeting with the President after the award.. And Dr. King (awarded 1964) got it for his opposition to the parallel policy in America.

Re:Jailed Iranian Activist Narges Mohammadi Wins 2023 Nobel ... by imjonse on Friday October 06, 2023 @11:45AM (#37792320)
You are right. Although those recipients were clearly in favor of non-violent fighting for human rights and were not explicitly anti-western or anti-US (the definitions of non-recipients this subthread started with) When Dr King began opposing the Vietnam war instead of simply fighting for equal rights at home he became a larger menace.
Re:Jailed Iranian Activist Narges Mohammadi Wins 2023 Nobel ... by fauigerzigerk on Friday October 06, 2023 @12:45PM (#37793060)
The definition of non-recipients was never tied to violence. The examples given were Edward Snowden, Julian Assange and Chelsea Manning, all peaceful activists or journalists.
Re:Jailed Iranian Activist Narges Mohammadi Wins 2023 Nobel ... by imjonse on Friday October 06, 2023 @04:42PM (#37796133)
Media made sure these three were tied to violence.