News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Game Publishers Are Obsolete – So Why Haven’t Developers ... by angersock on Friday March 30, 2012 @05:38PM (#3778216)
There's no excuse for not being able to make a game of at least Counterstrike quality anymore.

Our tools have come so far, and our computers have become so cheap, that the barrier to entry to making a solid, fun, good-looking game is removed. Gone. Poof!

All you need to do is be willing to learn and stubborn enough to execute, and you'll make it.

And you know what else?

We need this. We need hordes of little velociraptor indies to outbreed and outsell publishers. We need the bloated megacorp AbstractGameFactorys to die. We need to free up the IP, we need to encourage genuine risk-taking and technological progress, and we need to do our damnedest to kill off these fuckers before they irrecoverably damage the market and the gamers.

Re:Game Publishers Are Obsolete – So Why Haven’t Developers ... by groby_b on Friday March 30, 2012 @06:28PM (#3778427)
The art assets for CS:S alone are quite a chunk of money to produce. Sure, we have great tools, and computers are cheap - but the artists working on assets aren't. And the number of assets, plus the work that goes into it, is _insane_.

As for the "all you need part" - I've friends who've gone indie, and it's a _very_ painful route, with far from guaranteed success. Have you actually tried it?

Re:Game Publishers Are Obsolete – So Why Haven’t Developers ... by angersock on Friday March 30, 2012 @06:56PM (#3778539)
So, notice that I said Counterstrike (the original Half-Life mod), not CS:S--mostly made by two dudes at the start.

Note also that we need to solve the art asset production problem--look at sites like cgtextures or similar for stabs at this. Look at procedural content and better tools like Unity. Those are some examples of how we can make assets cheaper and artists' lives easier.

As for trying to be an indie... job in progress (check my profile).

Re:Game Publishers Are Obsolete – So Why Haven’t Developers ... by groby_b on Friday March 30, 2012 @07:44PM (#3778685)
Even those two dudes took about two years. And they had support from Valve from Beta4 on.

As for cgtextures, it's a useless site for a high-polish game - the textures are inconsistent in style and quality. (And that's what causes the real cost, polish). Believe me, I've looked at procedural content for a long time, and it's still a far cry from ready.

What we might see fairly soon is human-assisted procedural content, especially for all those areas of the game that are just there for ambience, not for actual gameplay. Even then, it's a large amount.

But then again, you'll find out all that for yourself :) (Good luck with that venture!)

Re:Game Publishers Are Obsolete – So Why Haven’t Developers ... by angersock on Friday March 30, 2012 @08:08PM (#3778745)
(Thanks! We're banking pretty heavily on assisted procedural content!)

I'm genuinely curious how much "polish" is actually needed and required by gamers.

My theory is that publishers have push the market to the point where games are very similar (not a bad thing in and of itself, but not inaccurate either) and so the differentiating factor for driving sales and advertising is visuals. That being the case, the increasingly far end of the tail of visual fidelity is being mined heavily, and "polish" is getting more and more and more expensive.

So, I think that you can get by on pretty solid gameplay and alright polish without needing to get a publisher to fund you--after all, it was their business model that made it so expensive to start with.

Does that seem like a reasonable conclusion?

Re:Game Publishers Are Obsolete – So Why Haven’t Developers ... by groby_b on Friday March 30, 2012 @09:16PM (#3778945)
It's a possible conclusion. I wouldn't bet on it. Pretty much everywhere, the only two things that get eyeballs in significant amounts are novelty or polish. I mean, look at FB games - the company that's taking the market is rather unoriginal, but polishes the heck out of every game they ship.

They just found a way of doing that that is less asset intensive than "visual fidelity".

If you've found another way to make that work, you're set. But you pretty much by definition need to make an entirely different kind of game.

Re:Game Publishers Are Obsolete – So Why Haven’t Developers ... by jay_kyburz on Friday March 30, 2012 @05:53PM (#3778289)
I don't know why you are getting downvoted angersock, I agree.

An indie team that knows their stuff could give the big boys a run for their money.

I've been a lead on several AAA games at 2K and without a doubt a team of 5-6 guys and the Unreal Engine can make a smash hit game.

I cant image the teams for Portal or Team Fortress are very big.

Re:Game Publishers Are Obsolete – So Why Haven’t Developers ... by res0nat0r on Friday March 30, 2012 @05:47PM (#3778257)
Why can't there be room for both? I want the next MegaCorp MMO from Blizzard, which isn't possible from someone like an indie shop.
Re:Game Publishers Are Obsolete – So Why Haven’t Developers ... by zanny on Friday March 30, 2012 @07:46PM (#3778688)
League of Legends started out tiny and they are bigger in the "mmo" space than WoW is in terms of active players. Definitely not in terms of revenue, but they are definitely indie gone huge.

And they now have the staff to add new characters to the game every two weeks. The WoW devs add new wireframe modeled mobs maybe a half dozen times an expansion.