The thing that would keep me from joining (assuming my group didn't make the YC cut), like many other applicants to YC, is that I have a geographical disadvantage, and the modest stipend ends up making the relocation (and the dinners) possible.
A YCx would likely not provide that stipend, so colocating a group of founders for a dinner (and especially multiple dinners) would get prohibitively expensive outside of certain geographic locations where enough teams live (I can see a YCx in Boston, or LA, or Austin working out).
There's still probably 10 bay area rejected applicants per acceptee, so this is still a very worthwhile project.
I am based in NYC, so I can see that happening here. I am not sure where you are based but if your city has at least 50k to 100k people, you can probably get a few startups together.
And on dinner. Aren't we supposed to be just trying to get to ramen profitable ? :)
if you are working on a startup and not already in an incubator, would you join?