News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s war on Android gets major blow in the form of 199... by dpark on Friday March 30, 2012 @11:42AM (#3776490)
> A faked teck demo's basically count as fiction which does not count as prior art for a normal patent case

Why would it not count as prior art if it demonstrates the patented method? Supposedly the original patent on the modern waterbed could not be defended because such a similar device had been described by Heinlein in SciFi books.

Re:Apple’s war on Android gets major blow in the form of 199... by Retric on Friday March 30, 2012 @12:11PM (#3776674)
Generally it's a description of a function missing a lot of details that make it useful. Consider, a waterbed needs to be close to persons body temperature and not room temperature to be comfortable. So if you actually built and patented a 'modern' waterbed for sale you would patent a temperature control system + plastic bag filled with water. So a description of a comfortable bed filled with water that allowed people to float to reduce the risk of bedsores would not include such issues.

However, Heinlein was not starting from scratch, people had been building them for 60 years and he actually described a lot of the details normally left out. Temperature control, safety, leaks, water level, floor load etc. So when someone tried to patent improvements their was prior art for both waterbeds and the obvious improvements to them.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waterbed#Heinlein_descriptions